Exercise and Health Laboratory, CIPER, Fac Motricidade Humana, Univ Tecn Lisboa, Cruz-Quebrada, Portugal.
Eur J Clin Nutr. 2013 Oct;67(10):1012-21. doi: 10.1038/ejcn.2013.148. Epub 2013 Aug 14.
BACKGROUND/OBJECTIVES: Dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA) is an accurate and reliable method for determining body composition, but a limiting feature is the restricted scanning areas (∼190 × 60 cm(2)). This shortcoming is relevant not only to athletes involved in sports where height is a major performance determinant but also to obese individuals with a large trunk mass and breadth in whom body dimensions frequently exceed the scan area. This study reviews solutions for DXA length and/or width limitations and its accuracy for body composition assessment using the PRISMA statement guidelines.
SUBJECTS/METHODS: Reviewed studies included English language articles from MEDLINE and Thomson Reuters Web of Knowledge platform (1990-2013), and were selected if procedures to overcome the scan area limitations and its validity in assessing the body composition of healthy participants were addressed. Search terms included: DXA, scan, height, width, length, wide, large, tall and obese.
A total of seven studies met the criteria and were selected. The sum of two DXA scans and adopting a knee-bent position are alternative procedures proposed for evaluating individuals using pencil and fan-beam Hologic instruments, who are taller than the scan area, whereas a half-body scan is recommended for overcoming the limitations of whole-body measurements in subjects who are wider than the scan area width of Lunar densitometers.
Overall, the proposed procedures are useful and valid, in particular the half-body scan alternative, which avoids unnecessary radiation exposure and scanning time. However, these alternatives were developed for specific densitometers, models and scan mode, and applicability to other instruments requires further research.
背景/目的:双能 X 射线吸收法(DXA)是一种准确可靠的方法,可用于确定身体成分,但它的一个限制因素是受限于扫描区域(约 190×60cm²)。这个缺点不仅与身高是主要运动表现决定因素的运动员有关,也与躯干质量和宽度较大的肥胖个体有关,他们的身体尺寸经常超过扫描区域。本研究综述了 DXA 长度和/或宽度限制及其在使用 PRISMA 声明指南评估身体成分方面的准确性。
受试者/方法:综述的研究包括 MEDLINE 和汤姆森路透网(1990-2013 年)的英文文章,如果涉及到克服扫描区域限制的程序及其在评估健康参与者身体成分方面的有效性,则被选择纳入。搜索词包括:DXA、扫描、身高、宽度、长度、宽、大、高和肥胖。
共有 7 项研究符合标准并被选择。对于使用铅笔和扇形束霍洛尼克仪器测量身高超过扫描区域的个体,可采用两次 DXA 扫描并采取膝盖弯曲的位置,或者建议使用半身扫描来克服 Lunar 密度计在测量宽度超过扫描区域的个体时的全身测量的限制。
总体而言,所提出的程序是有用和有效的,特别是半身扫描的替代方法,它可以避免不必要的辐射暴露和扫描时间。然而,这些替代方法是为特定的密度计、型号和扫描模式开发的,其在其他仪器上的适用性需要进一步研究。