Mendoza-Ticona Alberto, Moore David A J, Alarcón Valentina, Samalvides Frine, Seas Carlos
Instituto Nacional de Salud, Lima, Perú
Rev Peru Med Exp Salud Publica. 2013 Apr;30(2):197-204.
To elaborate optimal anti-tuberculosis regimens following drug susceptibility testing (DST) to isoniazid (H) and rifampicin (R).
12 311 strains (National Health Institute of Peru 2007-2009) were classified in four groups according H and R resistance. In each group the sensitivity to ethambutol (E), pirazinamide (Z), streptomycin (S), kanamycin (Km), capreomycin (Cm), ciprofloxacin (Cfx), ethionamide (Eto), cicloserine (Cs) and -amino salicilic acid (PAS) was determined. Based on resistance profiles, domestic costs, and following WHO guidelines, we elaborated and selected optimal putative regimens for each group. The potential efficacy (PE) variable was defined as the proportion of strains sensitive to at least three or four drugs for each regimen evaluated.
Selected regimes with the lowest cost, and highest PE of containing 3 and 4 effective drugs for TB sensitive to H and R were: HRZ (99,5%) and HREZ (99,1%), respectively; RZECfx (PE=98,9%) and RZECfxKm (PE=97,7%) for TB resistant to H; HZECfx (96,8%) and HZECfxKm (95,4%) for TB resistant to R; and EZCfxKmEtoCs (82.9%) for MDR-TB.
Based on resistance to H and R it was possible to select anti-tuberculosis regimens with high probability of success. This proposal is a feasible alternative to tackle tuberculosis in Peru where the access to rapid DST to H and R is improving progressively.
阐述针对异烟肼(H)和利福平(R)药敏试验(DST)后的最佳抗结核方案。
根据对H和R的耐药性,将12311株菌株(秘鲁国家卫生研究所2007 - 2009年)分为四组。测定每组对乙胺丁醇(E)、吡嗪酰胺(Z)、链霉素(S)、卡那霉素(Km)、卷曲霉素(Cm)、环丙沙星(Cfx)、乙硫异烟胺(Eto)、环丝氨酸(Cs)和对氨基水杨酸(PAS)的敏感性。根据耐药谱、国内成本并遵循世界卫生组织指南,我们为每组制定并选择了最佳假定方案。潜在疗效(PE)变量定义为每种评估方案中对至少三种或四种药物敏感的菌株比例。
对于对H和R敏感的结核病,选择成本最低且含3种和4种有效药物的PE最高的方案分别为:HRZ(99.5%)和HREZ(99.1%);对H耐药的结核病为RZECfx(PE = 98.9%)和RZECfxKm(PE = 97.7%);对R耐药的结核病为HZECfx(96.8%)和HZECfxKm(95.4%);耐多药结核病为EZCfxKmEtoCs(82.9%)。
基于对H和R的耐药性,有可能选择成功率高的抗结核方案。该提议是秘鲁应对结核病的一种可行选择,在秘鲁,对H和R进行快速DST的可及性正在逐步提高。