Aggarwal Tanuj, Materassi Donatello, Davison Robert, Hays Thomas, Salapaka Murti
Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, University of Minnesota, 200 Union St. SE, Minneapolis, MN 55455, USA.
Cell Mol Bioeng. 2012;5(1):14-31. doi: 10.1007/s12195-011-0188-5.
Over the past few decades, single molecule investigations employing optical tweezers, AFM and TIRF microscopy have revealed that molecular behaviors are typically characterized by discrete steps or events that follow changes in protein conformation. These events, that manifest as steps or jumps, are short-lived transitions between otherwise more stable molecular states. A major limiting factor in determining the size and timing of the steps is the noise introduced by the measurement system. To address this impediment to the analysis of single molecule behaviors, step detection algorithms incorporate large records of data and provide objective analysis. However, existing algorithms are mostly based on heuristics that are not reliable and lack objectivity. Most of these step detection methods require the user to supply parameters that inform the search for steps. They work well, only when the signal to noise ratio (SNR) is high and stepping speed is low. In this report, we have developed a novel step detection method that performs an objective analysis on the data without input parameters, and based only on the noise statistics. The noise levels and characteristics can be estimated from the data providing reliable results for much smaller SNR and higher stepping speeds. An iterative learning process drives the optimization of step-size distributions for data that has unimodal step-size distribution, and produces extremely low false positive outcomes and high accuracy in finding true steps. Our novel methodology, also uniquely incorporates compensation for the smoothing affects of probe dynamics. A mechanical measurement probe typically takes a finite time to respond to step changes, and when steps occur faster than the probe response time, the sharp step transitions are smoothed out and can obscure the step events. To address probe dynamics we accept a model for the dynamic behavior of the probe and invert it to reveal the steps. No other existing method addresses the impact of probe dynamics on step detection. Importantly, we have also developed a comprehensive set of tools to evaluate various existing step detection techniques. We quantify the performance and limitations of various step detection methods using novel evaluation scales. We show that under these scales, our method provides much better overall performance. The method is validated on different simulated test cases, as well as experimental data.
在过去几十年中,利用光镊、原子力显微镜和全内反射荧光显微镜进行的单分子研究表明,分子行为通常以离散的步骤或事件为特征,这些步骤或事件伴随着蛋白质构象的变化。这些表现为台阶或跳跃的事件,是在其他更稳定的分子状态之间的短暂转变。确定这些步骤的大小和时间的一个主要限制因素是测量系统引入的噪声。为了解决这一分析单分子行为的障碍,步长检测算法整合了大量数据记录并提供客观分析。然而,现有算法大多基于不可靠且缺乏客观性的启发式方法。这些步长检测方法大多需要用户提供用于搜索步长的参数。只有当信噪比(SNR)高且步速低时,它们才能很好地工作。在本报告中,我们开发了一种新颖的步长检测方法,该方法无需输入参数,仅基于噪声统计对数据进行客观分析。可以从数据中估计噪声水平和特征,从而为小得多的信噪比和更高的步速提供可靠结果。对于具有单峰步长分布的数据,迭代学习过程驱动步长分布的优化,并在找到真实步长时产生极低的误报率和高精度。我们的新方法还独特地纳入了对探针动力学平滑效应的补偿。机械测量探针通常需要有限的时间来响应步长变化,当步长发生的速度比探针响应时间快时,尖锐的步长转变会被平滑,从而可能掩盖步长事件。为了解决探针动力学问题,我们采用了一个探针动态行为模型并对其进行反演以揭示步长。没有其他现有方法解决探针动力学对步长检测的影响。重要的是,我们还开发了一套全面的工具来评估各种现有的步长检测技术。我们使用新颖的评估尺度量化各种步长检测方法的性能和局限性。我们表明,在这些尺度下,我们的方法提供了更好的整体性能。该方法在不同的模拟测试案例以及实验数据上得到了验证。