Bumb Anja, Seifert Burkhard, Wetzel Stephan, Agosti Reto
University of Basel, Zürich, Switzerland.
Springerplus. 2013 Aug 10;2:377. doi: 10.1186/2193-1801-2-377. eCollection 2013.
To evaluate if white matter lesions (WML) on MRI can be a potential marker for onabotulinum toxin A (Botox®) treatment success in migraine, given the limited response rate and high costs per treatment.
Retrospective data base and MRI analysis of 529 migraineurs who received Botox® between 2002 and 2009. Responders were defined as patients who underwent three or more treatments, whereas non-responders had only one or two treatments. MRIs were analysed on axial T2 and coronar FLAIR (fluid attenuated inversion recovery) sequences for the presence of WML. Statistical analysis was done with the Chi-Square-Test and the Mann-Whitney-U-Test.
Of 529 Botox® treated migraineurs, 111 patients had a MRI. Of these 111 patients, 47 were responders, 64 non-responders to Botox®. Response rate to Botox® in migraineurs with WML was 55.3%, in migraineurs without WML 44.7%. In the investigated items "age", "age at onset", "gender", "attack duration", "frequency", "aura", "WML", "size of WML", we found no statistical significant difference between the two groups. 55% of the responders and 50% of the non-responders showed WML. All WML were located supratentorially, anteriorly, mostly of small size (3-5 mm).
WML on MRIs cannot serve as a marker to predict a positive response to Botox®.
鉴于肉毒杆菌毒素A(保妥适®)治疗偏头痛的有效率有限且每次治疗成本高昂,评估MRI上的白质病变(WML)是否可作为肉毒杆菌毒素A治疗偏头痛成功的潜在标志物。
对2002年至2009年间接受保妥适®治疗的529例偏头痛患者进行回顾性数据库分析和MRI分析。有反应者定义为接受三次或更多次治疗的患者,无反应者仅接受一或两次治疗。在轴向T2和冠状面液体衰减反转恢复(FLAIR)序列上分析MRI,以确定是否存在WML。采用卡方检验和曼-惠特尼-U检验进行统计分析。
在529例接受保妥适®治疗的偏头痛患者中,111例患者进行了MRI检查。在这111例患者中,47例有反应,64例对保妥适®无反应。有WML的偏头痛患者对保妥适®的反应率为55.3%,无WML的偏头痛患者反应率为44.7%。在“年龄”“发病年龄”“性别”“发作持续时间”“频率”“先兆”“WML”“WML大小”等研究项目中,两组之间无统计学显著差异。55%的有反应者和50%的无反应者显示有WML。所有WML均位于幕上、前部,大多为小尺寸(3 - 5毫米)。
MRI上的WML不能作为预测对保妥适®产生阳性反应的标志物。