Department of Clinical Science and Education and Section of Emergency Medicine, Södersjukhuset, Karolinska Institutet, Stockholm, Sweden.
Scand J Trauma Resusc Emerg Med. 2013 Sep 11;21:68. doi: 10.1186/1757-7241-21-68.
Registration of data from a major incident or disaster serves several purposes such as to record data for evaluation of response as well as for research. Data needed can often be retrieved after an incident while other must be recorded during the incident. There is a need for a consensus on what is essential to record from a disaster response. The aim of this study was to identify key indicators essential for initial disaster medical response registration. By this is meant nationally accepted processes involved, from the time of the emergency call to the emergency medical communication centre until medical care is provided at the emergency department.
A three round Delphi study was conducted. Thirty experts with a broad knowledge in disaster and emergency response and medical management were invited. In this study we estimated 30 experts to be approximately one third of the number in Sweden eligible for recruitment. Process, structure and outcome indicators for the initial disaster medical response were identified. These were based on previous research and expressed as statements and were grouped into eight categories, and presented to the panel of experts. The experts were instructed to score each statement, using a five point Likert scale, and were also invited to include additional statements. Statements reaching a predefined consensus level of 80% were considered as essential to register.
In total 97 statements were generated, 77 statements reached consensus. The 77 statements covered parts of all relevant aspects involved in the initial disaster medical response. The 20 indicators that did not reach consensus mostly concerned patient related times in hospital, types of support systems and security for health care staff.
The Delphi technique can be used for reaching consensus of data, comprising process, structure and outcome indicators, identified as essential for recording from major incidents and disasters.
重大事件或灾害的数据登记有多种用途,例如记录响应数据以便评估,以及用于研究。通常可以在事件发生后检索所需的数据,而其他数据则必须在事件发生期间记录。需要就灾害应对中必须记录哪些内容达成共识。本研究的目的是确定初始灾害医疗应对登记所需的关键指标。这是指从紧急呼叫到紧急医疗通讯中心,再到急诊科提供医疗服务的国家认可的过程。
进行了三轮 Delphi 研究。邀请了 30 名具有广泛灾害和应急响应以及医疗管理知识的专家参加。在这项研究中,我们估计有 30 名专家,大约是瑞典有资格招募的专家的三分之一。确定了初始灾害医疗应对的过程、结构和结果指标。这些指标基于先前的研究,并表示为陈述,并分为八个类别,提交给专家组。专家们被指示使用五点 Likert 量表对每个陈述进行评分,并被邀请添加其他陈述。达到 80%预定共识水平的陈述被认为是必须登记的。
共产生了 97 个陈述,其中 77 个陈述达成共识。这 77 个陈述涵盖了初始灾害医疗应对中所有相关方面的部分内容。没有达成共识的 20 个陈述主要涉及患者在医院的相关时间、支持系统的类型和医护人员的安全。
Delphi 技术可用于达成共识,确定从重大事件和灾害中记录所需的数据,包括过程、结构和结果指标。