Department of Health and Sports, Niigata University of Health and Welfare, Niigata, Japan.
PLoS One. 2013 Sep 10;8(9):e74716. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0074716. eCollection 2013.
Japan has implemented various school actions during seasonal influenza outbreaks since the 1950's under the School Health Law. However, the effective duration, extent, and timing of closures remain unresolved.
We conducted a retrospective study on the relationship between elementary class closures and influenza outbreak control during four consecutive influenza seasons from the 2004-2005 to 2007-2008 school years in Joetsu, Niigata, Japan. Among a total of 1,061 classes of 72 schools, 624 cases of influenza outbreaks were documented among 61 schools.
Class closures were carried out in a total of 62 cases in response to influenza outbreak, which was defined as a student absentee rate of greater than 10% due to influenza or influenza-like illness. Of these cases, two-day class closures were conducted the day after reaching a 10% student absentee rate in 28 cases and other types of closures were initiated in 34 cases. A markedly higher number of outbreak cases ended within one week for two-day class closures compared to the other types of closures (82.1% vs. 20.6%, respectively). The significant association between two-day class closures and interruption of an outbreak within one week was confirmed using a multivariable model adjusted for the season, grade, day of the week of an outbreak start, and absentee rate on the day of an outbreak start (OR, 3.18; 95% CI, 1.12-9.07; p = 0.030).
Our results suggest that a two-day class closure carried out the day after reaching a 10% absentee rate is an effective approach for mitigating influenza outbreaks in elementary schools.
自 20 世纪 50 年代以来,日本一直在《学校卫生法》的框架下针对季节性流感疫情采取各种学校防疫措施。然而,停课的有效持续时间、范围和时机仍未得到解决。
我们对日本新潟县越后市四个连续流感季节(2004-2005 学年至 2007-2008 学年)的小学班级关闭与流感疫情控制之间的关系进行了回顾性研究。在总共 1061 个班级的 72 所学校中,记录了 61 所学校的 624 例流感暴发。
共有 62 例流感暴发被定义为因流感或流感样疾病导致的学生缺勤率超过 10%,因此采取了班级关闭措施。其中,28 例在达到 10%的学生缺勤率的次日实施了为期两天的停课,34 例则采取了其他类型的停课。为期两天的停课使暴发结束时间在一周内的病例数明显多于其他类型的停课(分别为 82.1%和 20.6%)。使用多变量模型调整了季节、年级、暴发开始日的星期几以及暴发开始日的缺勤率等因素后,确认了两天停课与一周内中断暴发之间存在显著关联(OR,3.18;95%CI,1.12-9.07;p=0.030)。
我们的研究结果表明,在达到 10%的缺勤率的次日实施为期两天的停课是缓解小学流感暴发的有效方法。