Institute of Legal Medicine, University Hospital Essen, Hufelandstr. 55, 45122, Essen, Germany,
Int J Legal Med. 2013 Nov;127(6):1093-6. doi: 10.1007/s00414-013-0916-6. Epub 2013 Sep 19.
In crime scene investigations, DNA left by touch on an object can be found frequently and the significant improvements in short tandem repeat (STR) amplification in recent years built up a high expectation to identify the individual(s) who touched the object by their DNA profile. Nevertheless, the percentage of reliably analysable samples varies considerably between different crime scenes even if the nature of the stains appears to be very similar. Here, it has been proposed that the amount and quality of DNA left at a crime scene may be influenced by external factors (like nature of the surface) and/or individual factors (like skin conditions). In this study, the influence of the age of an individual who left his DNA on an object is investigated. Handprints from 213 individuals (1 to 89 years old) left on a plastic syringe were analysed for DNA amount and STR alleles using Quantifiler® and PowerPlex® ESX 17. A full profile of the individual could be found in 75 % of all children up to 10 years, 9 % of adolescents (11 to 20 years), 25 % of adults (21 to 60 years) and 8 % of elderly people (older than 60 years). No person older than 80 years displayed a full profile. Drop-in and drop-out artefacts occurred frequently throughout the age groups. A dependency of quantity and quality of the DNA left on a touched object on the age of the individual could be clearly demonstrated at least for children and elderly people. An epithelial abrasion unexpectedly good to interpret may be derived from a child, whereas the suspected skin contact of an elderly person with an object may be impossible to prove.
在犯罪现场调查中,经常可以在物体上触摸到的 DNA 留下的痕迹,近年来短串联重复序列(STR)扩增技术的显著进步,使人们对通过 DNA 图谱识别触摸过物体的个人产生了很高的期望。然而,即使污渍的性质看起来非常相似,不同犯罪现场的可靠分析样本比例差异很大。有人提出,犯罪现场留下的 DNA 的数量和质量可能受到外部因素(如表面性质)和/或个体因素(如皮肤状况)的影响。在这项研究中,研究了在犯罪现场留下 DNA 的个体的年龄对 DNA 数量和 STR 等位基因的影响。使用 Quantifiler® 和 PowerPlex® ESX 17 分析了 213 个人(1 至 89 岁)留在塑料注射器上的手印的 DNA 数量和 STR 等位基因。在所有 10 岁以下的儿童中,75%的人可以找到完整的个人资料,11 至 20 岁的青少年中有 9%,21 至 60 岁的成年人中有 25%,60 岁以上的老年人中有 8%。没有超过 80 岁的人显示出完整的个人资料。在整个年龄组中,经常出现 Dropping-in 和 Dropping-out 伪迹。至少可以清楚地证明,留在触摸物体上的 DNA 的数量和质量与个体的年龄有关,至少对于儿童和老年人是如此。可能是一个孩子造成的上皮擦伤,这种擦伤可能出人意料地容易解释,而老年人与物体的可疑皮肤接触可能无法证明。