The Falk Institute for Mental Health Studies, Kfar Shaul Hospital, Givat Shaul, 91060 Jerusalem, Israel; Social Work Department, Ben Gurion University of the Negev, 84105 Beer Sheva, Israel.
Complement Ther Med. 2013 Oct;21(5):517-24. doi: 10.1016/j.ctim.2013.08.010. Epub 2013 Aug 22.
The study examines the difference in characteristics between primary care patients who turn to "religious resources for medical purposes" (RRMP) and those who turn to "complementary or alternative medicine" (CAM) services to cope with a physical or mental health problem.
Data were collected from eight primary care clinics in Israel and included 905 Jewish patients aged 25-75.
A self-report questionnaire with a battery of validated mental health assessment instruments and two questionnaires regarding use of unconventional therapies (RRMP and CAM services) were administered to the participants. The association of various variables with type of 'service use' was examined through logistic regression analysis.
Primary care patients suffering from emotional problems have a propensity to utilize unconventional therapies in addition to conventional medical treatment. However, differences exist between patients who turn to RRMP and to CAM. The risk factors for turning to RRMP are North African, Middle Eastern or Israeli origin, low SES, religious observance, and high use of primary care clinics. For using CAM services the risk factor is high SES.
In the present study, a quarter of primary care patients also use additional resources for their medical problems. While all segments of the population use unconventional resources, our study reveals that two types of unconventional therapies - RRMP and CAM - tend to be used by two different population sectors. It is noteworthy that those suffering from mental health problems are more likely to utilize unconventional resources.
本研究旨在考察在寻求“医学目的宗教资源”(RRMP)和“补充或替代医学”(CAM)服务以应对身心健康问题的初级保健患者之间,其特征存在何种差异。
数据来自以色列的 8 家初级保健诊所,共纳入 905 名年龄在 25-75 岁之间的犹太患者。
参与者接受了一份自我报告问卷,其中包含一系列经过验证的心理健康评估工具,以及两份关于非常规治疗方法(RRMP 和 CAM 服务)使用情况的问卷。通过逻辑回归分析,研究了各种变量与“服务使用”类型之间的关联。
患有情绪问题的初级保健患者除了接受常规医疗治疗外,还有倾向使用非常规疗法。然而,RRMP 和 CAM 的使用者之间存在差异。RRMP 的使用风险因素包括北非、中东或以色列血统、低社会经济地位、宗教信仰和对初级保健诊所的高利用率。而高社会经济地位则是使用 CAM 服务的风险因素。
在本研究中,四分之一的初级保健患者也会为其医疗问题额外寻求其他资源。尽管所有人群都在使用非常规资源,但我们的研究表明,两种类型的非常规疗法——RRMP 和 CAM——倾向于被两个不同的人群群体使用。值得注意的是,那些患有心理健康问题的人更有可能使用非常规资源。