Taggart Ian H, Ranney Megan L, Howland Jonathan, Mello Michael J
Injury Prevention Center at Rhode Island Hospital, Department of Emergency Medicine, Alpert School of Medicine at Brown University, Providence, Rhode Island.
J Emerg Med. 2013 Dec;45(6):962-8. doi: 10.1016/j.jemermed.2013.05.065. Epub 2013 Sep 21.
Alcohol use in college-age individuals is associated with increased injury risk. Many college drinkers end up in the emergency department (ED) as a result of their drinking, providing a unique opportunity to intervene.
This systematic review evaluates the existing evidence for the use of brief ED interventions for alcohol use in the college-age population.
A systematic search of on-line databases was conducted. Articles were limited to those in English published since 1990. Studies were included if they specifically studied 18- to 20-year-old alcohol users, if they were performed in an ED or acute care setting, and if an intervention regarding alcohol use was attempted.
There were 400 studies identified; 60 abstracts were reviewed, 18 full-text articles were evaluated, and 7 met the inclusion criteria for review. Eligible studies focused on alcohol use only, except for one study that addressed alcohol and other drug use. All examined changes in alcohol intake patterns as a primary outcome, and most also looked for reductions in alcohol-related harm. Each found reductions in alcohol intake patterns or reductions in alcohol-related harm in the intervention group, although some between-group differences were not statistically significant reductions.
Seven studies were identified that measured the outcomes of ED interventions for alcohol use in the college-age population. The studied interventions showed promise but had variable success. More research is needed to establish short- and long-term efficacy, specifically in high-risk underage college students.
大学年龄段人群饮酒与受伤风险增加有关。许多大学生饮酒者因饮酒最终进入急诊科,这提供了一个独特的干预机会。
本系统评价评估了在大学年龄段人群中使用急诊科简短干预措施来解决饮酒问题的现有证据。
对在线数据库进行了系统检索。文章仅限于1990年以来发表的英文文章。如果研究专门针对18至20岁的饮酒者,在急诊科或急性护理环境中进行,并且尝试了关于饮酒的干预措施,则纳入研究。
共识别出400项研究;审查了60篇摘要,评估了18篇全文文章,7篇符合纳入审查标准。符合条件的研究仅关注饮酒问题,只有一项研究涉及饮酒和其他药物使用。所有研究均将饮酒模式的变化作为主要结局进行考察,大多数研究还关注与饮酒相关危害的减少情况。每项研究均发现干预组的饮酒模式有所减少或与饮酒相关的危害有所降低,尽管一些组间差异在统计学上并非显著降低。
共识别出7项研究,这些研究测量了在大学年龄段人群中针对饮酒问题的急诊科干预措施的效果。所研究的干预措施显示出一定前景,但成效各异。需要更多研究来确定短期和长期疗效,特别是在高风险的未成年大学生中。