Physical Sciences Division, Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, 902 Battelle Boulevard, P.O. Box 999, MS K1-83, Richland, Washington 99352, USA.
J Chem Phys. 2013 Sep 21;139(11):114302. doi: 10.1063/1.4820448.
We report the first optimum geometries and harmonic vibrational frequencies for the ring pentamer and several water hexamer (prism, cage, cyclic and two book) at the coupled-cluster including single, double, and full perturbative triple excitations (CCSD(T))/aug-cc-pVDZ level of theory. All five examined hexamer isomer minima previously reported by Møller-Plesset perturbation theory (MP2) are also minima on the CCSD(T) potential energy surface (PES). In addition, all CCSD(T) minimum energy structures for the n = 2-6 cluster isomers are quite close to the ones previously obtained by MP2 on the respective PESs, as confirmed by a modified Procrustes analysis that quantifies the difference between any two cluster geometries. The CCSD(T) results confirm the cooperative effect of the homodromic ring networks (systematic contraction of the nearest-neighbor (nn) intermolecular separations with cluster size) previously reported by MP2, albeit with O-O distances shorter by ~0.02 Å, indicating that MP2 overcorrects this effect. The harmonic frequencies at the minimum geometries were obtained by the double differentiation of the CCSD(T) energy using an efficient scheme based on internal coordinates that reduces the number of required single point energy evaluations by ~15% when compared to the corresponding double differentiation using Cartesian coordinates. Negligible differences between MP2 and CCSD(T) frequencies are found for the librational modes, while uniform increases of ~15 and ~25 cm(-1) are observed for the bending and "free" OH harmonic frequencies. The largest differences between CCSD(T) and MP2 are observed for the harmonic hydrogen bonded frequencies, for which the former produces larger absolute values than the latter. Their CCSD(T) redshifts from the monomer values (Δω) are smaller than the MP2 ones, due to the fact that CCSD(T) produces shorter elongations (ΔR) of the respective hydrogen bonded OH lengths from the monomer value with respect to MP2. Both the MP2 and CCSD(T) results for the hydrogen bonded frequencies were found to closely follow the relation -Δω = s · ΔR, with a rate of s = 20.2 cm(-1)/0.001 Å for hydrogen bonded frequencies with IR intensities >400 km/mol. The CCSD(T) harmonic frequencies, when corrected using the MP2 anharmonicities obtained from second order vibrational perturbation theory, produce anharmonic CCSD(T) estimates that are within <60 cm(-1) from the measured infrared (IR) active bands of the n = 2-6 clusters. Furthermore, the CCSD(T) harmonic redshifts (with respect to the monomer) trace the measured ones quite accurately. The energetic order between the various hexamer isomers on the PES (prism has the lowest energy) previously reported at MP2 was found to be preserved at the CCSD(T) level, whereas the inclusion of anharmonic corrections further stabilizes the cage among the hexamer isomers.
我们报告了在耦合簇包括单、双和全微扰三激发(CCSD(T))/aug-cc-pVDZ 理论水平下,环五聚体和几个水六聚体(棱柱、笼、环状和两书)的首次最佳几何形状和调和振动频率。以前由 Møller-Plesset 微扰理论(MP2)报告的所有五种六聚体异构体最小值也都是 CCSD(T)势能表面(PES)上的最小值。此外,n=2-6 团簇异构体的所有 CCSD(T)最低能量结构都与以前在各自 PES 上由 MP2 获得的结构非常接近,这一点得到了改进的 Procrustes 分析的证实,该分析量化了任意两个团簇几何形状之间的差异。CCSD(T) 结果证实了以前由 MP2 报告的同旋环网络(随着团簇尺寸的增大,最近邻(nn)分子间距离的系统收缩)的协同效应,尽管 O-O 距离缩短了约 0.02 Å,表明 MP2 对此效应过度校正。通过使用基于内部坐标的有效方案,从 CCSD(T) 能量中双微分获得最小几何形状的调和频率,与使用笛卡尔坐标进行的相应双微分相比,可将所需单点能量评估的数量减少约 15%。对于旋转模式,MP2 和 CCSD(T) 频率之间几乎没有差异,而弯曲和“自由”OH 调和频率则均匀增加约 15 和 25 cm(-1)。CCSD(T) 和 MP2 之间观察到的最大差异是对于调和氢键频率,前者产生的绝对值大于后者。它们的 CCSD(T) 红移(相对于单体的 Δω)小于 MP2 的红移,这是因为 CCSD(T) 产生的相应氢键 OH 长度的伸长(相对于 MP2 的 ΔR)比 MP2 短。氢键频率的 MP2 和 CCSD(T) 结果都被发现密切遵循关系-Δω=s·ΔR,其中 s=20.2 cm(-1)/0.001 Å,对于 IR 强度大于 400 km/mol 的氢键频率。使用二阶振动微扰理论获得的 MP2 非谐性校正 CCSD(T) 调和频率,产生的非谐 CCSD(T) 估计值与 n=2-6 团簇的测量红外(IR)活性带相差小于 60 cm(-1)。此外,CCSD(T) 调和红移(相对于单体)非常准确地跟踪了测量值。在以前由 MP2 报告的 PES(棱柱体具有最低能量)上各种六聚体异构体之间的能量顺序被发现保存在 CCSD(T) 水平上,而包括非谐校正进一步稳定了六聚体异构体中的笼体。