Division of Bioengineering, School of Chemical and Biomedical Engineering, Nanyang Technological University, Singapore 637457.
Med Phys. 2013 Oct;40(10):103301. doi: 10.1118/1.4810935.
Gold nanorods have the potential to enhance the treatment efficacy of interstitial photothermal therapy. In order to enhance both the potential efficiency and the safety of such procedures, treatment planning on laser power density, nanoparticle concentration, and exposure time has turned out to be useful in predicting the thermal damage and optimizing treatment outcome. To the best of our knowledge, there is no previous report on the optimization of interstitial plasmonic photothermal therapy (PPTT) for all these free parameters simultaneously. The authors propose to develop a suitable optimization algorithm for interstitial PPTT to optimize these parameters and achieve complete damage to spherical tumors of different sizes with a damage margin width of 1 mm from the tumor boundary embedded deep inside a normal tissue model.
In a numerical tissue model, the standard Pennes bioheat equation and the first-order thermal-chemical rate equation were used to model the temperature and thermal damage distributions, respectively, in spherical tumors that were embedded deep inside a normal tissue and incubated with nanorods. The concentration of nanorods in the normal tissue was set to be about one quarter of that in the tumor. Thermal damage due to varying concentrations of nanorods, laser power density, and exposure time was computed for a series of tumor radii including 2, 3, 4, and 5 mm. An optimization algorithm was developed to determine the optimum laser power density, nanorod concentration, and exposure time for the treatment of such spherical tumors. In this algorithm, a novel objective function was created to enable the optimization of multiple key parameters, including nanoparticle concentration, power density, and exposure time, simultaneously to achieve not only the complete thermal damage to the entire tumor but also the collateral damage to the surrounding normal tissue with a margin width of 1 mm from the tumor boundary. Different weights were assigned sequentially to each free parameter according to the relative importance of the parameters. A thermal damage value of one calculated by Arrhenius damage law, which is more accurate than a threshold temperature typically used for characterizing thermal damage, was used to indicate effective treatment.
The simulation results show that there is a steady increase in the overall temperature as the nanorod concentration increases; however, the uniformity of the temperature distribution changes significantly which in turn affects the thermal damage. Optimization results show that any slight decrease in one free parameter can be compensated by the increase in other free parameters, in which the complete thermal damage of the tumor and the collateral damage to normal tissue with a margin width of 1 mm can be always achieved. This implies the importance of optimization in interstitial PPTT.
The proposed method can optimize laser power density, nanoparticle concentration, and exposure time simultaneously with different weights in interstitial PPTT planning for deep seated tumors. It provides flexibility for a clinician to make appropriate planning for individual patients according to their special needs.
金纳米棒具有增强间质光热治疗效果的潜力。为了提高这些方法的潜在效率和安全性,对激光功率密度、纳米颗粒浓度和暴露时间的治疗规划已被证明有助于预测热损伤并优化治疗效果。据我们所知,目前尚无关于同时优化所有这些自由参数的间质等离子体光热治疗(PPTT)的报道。作者建议开发一种合适的间质 PPTT 优化算法,以优化这些参数,并用 1mm 的边界余量完全破坏嵌入正常组织模型深处的不同大小的球形肿瘤。
在数值组织模型中,使用标准的 Pennes 生物传热方程和一阶热化学速率方程分别模拟嵌入正常组织深处的球形肿瘤中的温度和热损伤分布。正常组织中纳米棒的浓度设定为肿瘤中浓度的四分之一。针对包括 2、3、4 和 5mm 在内的一系列肿瘤半径,计算了不同纳米棒浓度、激光功率密度和暴露时间下的热损伤。开发了一种优化算法来确定治疗此类球形肿瘤的最佳激光功率密度、纳米棒浓度和暴露时间。在该算法中,创建了一个新的目标函数,以能够同时优化多个关键参数,包括纳米颗粒浓度、功率密度和暴露时间,不仅要实现整个肿瘤的完全热损伤,还要在肿瘤边界 1mm 处实现对周围正常组织的附带损伤。根据参数的相对重要性,依次为每个自由参数分配不同的权重。采用更准确的 Arrhenius 损伤律计算的损伤值 1 来表示有效治疗。
模拟结果表明,随着纳米棒浓度的增加,整体温度会稳步升高;然而,温度分布的均匀性会发生显著变化,从而影响热损伤。优化结果表明,任何一个自由参数的微小下降都可以通过其他自由参数的增加来补偿,从而始终可以实现肿瘤的完全热损伤和 1mm 边界余量的正常组织附带损伤。这意味着在间质 PPTT 中优化的重要性。
该方法可在深部肿瘤的间质 PPTT 规划中同时优化激光功率密度、纳米颗粒浓度和暴露时间,并赋予临床医生根据患者的特殊需求为个体患者进行适当规划的灵活性。