Alschuler Daniel M, Tenke Craig E, Bruder Gerard E, Kayser Jürgen
Division of Cognitive Neuroscience, New York State Psychiatric Institute, New York, NY, USA.
Division of Cognitive Neuroscience, New York State Psychiatric Institute, New York, NY, USA; Department of Psychiatry, Columbia University College of Physicians & Surgeons, New York, NY, USA.
Clin Neurophysiol. 2014 Mar;125(3):484-90. doi: 10.1016/j.clinph.2013.08.024. Epub 2013 Oct 2.
EEG topographies may be distorted by electrode bridges, typically caused by electrolyte spreading between adjacent electrodes. We therefore sought to determine the prevalence of electrode bridging and its potential impact on the EEG literature.
Five publicly-available EEG datasets were evaluated for evidence of bridging using a new screening method that employs the temporal variance of pairwise difference waveforms (electrical distance). Distinctive characteristics of electrical distance frequency distributions were used to develop an algorithm to identify electrode bridges in datasets with different montages (22-64 channels) and noise properties.
The extent of bridging varied substantially across datasets: 54% of EEG recording sessions contained an electrode bridge, and the mean percentage of bridged electrodes in a montage was as high as 18% in one of the datasets. Furthermore, over 40% of the recording channels were bridged in 9 of 203 sessions. These findings were independently validated by visual inspection.
The new algorithm conveniently, efficiently, and reliably identified electrode bridges across different datasets and recording conditions. Electrode bridging may constitute a substantial problem for some datasets.
Given the extent of the electrode bridging across datasets, this problem may be more widespread than commonly thought. However, when used as an automatic screening routine, the new algorithm will prevent pitfalls stemming from unrecognized electrode bridges.
脑电图地形图可能会因电极桥接而失真,电极桥接通常是由电解质在相邻电极之间扩散引起的。因此,我们试图确定电极桥接的发生率及其对脑电图文献的潜在影响。
使用一种新的筛查方法,通过成对差异波形的时间方差(电距离),对五个公开可用的脑电图数据集进行桥接证据评估。利用电距离频率分布的独特特征开发一种算法,以识别具有不同导联方式(22 - 64个通道)和噪声特性的数据集中的电极桥接。
各数据集之间桥接程度差异很大:54%的脑电图记录时段包含电极桥接,在其中一个数据集中,导联方式中桥接电极的平均百分比高达18%。此外,在203个记录时段中的9个时段,超过40%的记录通道存在桥接。这些发现通过目视检查得到了独立验证。
新算法方便、高效且可靠地识别了不同数据集和记录条件下的电极桥接。电极桥接可能对某些数据集构成重大问题。
鉴于各数据集之间电极桥接的程度,这个问题可能比普遍认为的更为普遍。然而,当用作自动筛查程序时,新算法将避免因未识别的电极桥接而产生的问题。