Department of Psychology, Iowa State University, 50011, Ames, Iowa.
Mem Cognit. 1978 Sep;6(5):568-81. doi: 10.3758/BF03198246.
Four experiments using college students as subjects provide evidence that both highly skilled and less skilled mature readers derive the names of printed words from visual access of the lexicon rather than by phonological recoding. Regularity of pronunciation (regular vs. exception words) as a variable of orthographic regularity effectiveafter visual code formation had no effect either between or within reading ability groups. Less skilled readers made more errors and were slower than highly skilled readers on both types of words. Sing-letter spatial redundancy, as a variable of orthographic regularity that influences the formation of visual codes, served to differentiate the two groups only in naming nonwords. Highly skilled readers used spatial redundancy to offset the effect of array length, whereas less skilled readers did not. Except for high-frequency words, visual access and retrieval of the pronunciation of words was significantly faster for highly skilled readers. Less skilled readers were most disadvantaged in naming nonwords, a task that requires phonological recoding. Overall results support the hypothesis that reading ability in mature readers is related to the speed of word recognition. Highly skilled readers may make more use of variables of orthographic regularity effective in the formation of visual codes.
四项使用大学生作为被试的实验表明,无论是高技能还是低技能的成熟读者,他们都是从词汇的视觉通道中获取印刷单词的名称,而不是通过语音编码。发音规则(规则词与不规则词)作为影响视觉代码形成后的正字法规则的变量,在阅读能力组之间或组内均无影响。在这两种词上,低技能读者比高技能读者犯的错误更多,速度也更慢。作为影响视觉代码形成的正字法规则变量的单个字母空间冗余,仅在命名非词时能够区分这两组被试。高技能读者使用空间冗余来抵消数组长度的影响,而低技能读者则没有。除了高频词外,高技能读者在识别单词的发音时,视觉通道和检索速度都显著更快。在命名非词时,低技能读者最不利,因为这需要语音编码。总体结果支持这样一种假设,即成熟读者的阅读能力与单词识别的速度有关。高技能读者可能会更多地利用影响视觉代码形成的正字法规则变量。