Heather Natasha L, Derraik José G B, Beca John, Hofman Paul L, Dansey Rangi, Hamill James, Cutfield Wayne S
Liggins Institute, University of Auckland, Auckland, New Zealand.
PLoS One. 2013 Dec 2;8(12):e82245. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0082245. eCollection 2013.
To assess the association of the Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS) with radiological evidence of head injury (the Abbreviated Injury Scale for the head region, AIS-HR) in young children hospitalized with traumatic head injury (THI), and the predictive value of GCS and AIS-HR scores for long-term impairment.
Our study involved a 10-year retrospective review of a database encompassing all patients admitted to Starship Children's Hospital (Auckland, New Zealand, 2000-2010) with THI.
We studied 619 children aged <5 years at the time of THI, with long-term outcome data available for 161 subjects. Both GCS and AIS-HR scores were predictive of length of intensive care unit and hospital stay (all p<0.001). GCS was correlated with AIS-HR (ρ=-0.46; p<0.001), although mild GCS scores (13-15) commonly under-estimated the severity of radiological injury: 42% of children with mild GCS scores had serious-critical THI (AIS-HR 3-5). Increasingly severe GCS or AIS-HR scores were both associated with a greater likelihood of long-term impairment (neurological disability, residual problems, and educational support). However, long-term impairment was also relatively common in children with mild GCS scores paired with structural THI more severe than a simple linear skull fracture.
Severe GCS scores will identify most cases of severe radiological injury in early childhood, and are good predictors of poor long-term outcome. However, young children admitted to hospital with structural THI and mild GCS scores have an appreciable risk of long-term disability, and also warrant long-term follow-up.
评估格拉斯哥昏迷量表(GCS)与因创伤性脑损伤(THI)住院的幼儿头部损伤的放射学证据(头部区域简明损伤量表,AIS-HR)之间的关联,以及GCS和AIS-HR评分对长期损伤的预测价值。
我们的研究对一个数据库进行了为期10年的回顾性分析,该数据库涵盖了所有入住星际儿童医院(新西兰奥克兰,2000 - 2010年)的THI患者。
我们研究了619名THI发生时年龄小于5岁的儿童,其中161名受试者有长期结局数据。GCS和AIS-HR评分均能预测重症监护病房住院时间和住院总时长(所有p<0.001)。GCS与AIS-HR相关(ρ=-0.46;p<0.001),尽管轻度GCS评分(13 - 15分)通常会低估放射学损伤的严重程度:42%的轻度GCS评分儿童患有严重 - 极重度THI(AIS-HR 3 - 5分)。GCS或AIS-HR评分越严重,长期损伤(神经功能残疾、残留问题和教育支持需求)的可能性越大。然而,GCS评分轻度但伴有比单纯线性颅骨骨折更严重的结构性THI的儿童中,长期损伤也相对常见。
严重的GCS评分能识别出大多数幼儿严重放射学损伤病例,并且是长期不良结局的良好预测指标。然而,因结构性THI入院且GCS评分轻度的幼儿有明显的长期残疾风险,也需要长期随访。