Lous Jørgen
Research Unit of General Practice, Institute of Public Health, University of Southern Denmark, Denmark.
Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol. 2014 Jan;78(1):124-7. doi: 10.1016/j.ijporl.2013.11.003. Epub 2013 Nov 20.
Otitis media has been a serious disease and can be that even today. The diagnosis of otitis media is often difficult. Pneumatic otoscopy, otomicroscopy, and tympanometry can improve the diagnostic quality by indication of fluid in the middle ear and thereby improve the quality of treatment. The aim of this ongoing study is to analyze the use of tympanometry in Denmark after reimbursement for doing tympanometry (November 2006) when clinically indicated. Our research questions were: How many clinics were using tympanometry? How frequent was it used? Is the use increasing? Has the number of GPs in the clinic any relation to the use of tympanometry?
We used information in The Danish National Health Service in three Regions to analyze the use of tympanometry in general practice during the years 2007-2009. The coverage of the GPs is 100% in the regions.
The three regions counted about half of Danish population. In 2009 the material was 902 different clinics with more than 1700 GPs. In 2007 55% of the clinics did tympanometry, in 2009 the figure was 60%. In the clinics doing tympanometry the median value was 28 tympanometries per year (inter-quartile range 13-53) per GP. The variation in the use of tympanometry was surprisingly high, from none or a few per GP per year to a maximum of more than 500 tympanometric examinations per GP a year. This huge variation has to be discussed.
Many answers can be given. Some of the explanation was problems in doing correct tympanometry, and problems understand the clinical implications of curves and the figures.
中耳炎一直是一种严重的疾病,即便在当今亦是如此。中耳炎的诊断常常颇具难度。鼓气耳镜检查、耳显微镜检查和鼓室导抗图检查可通过显示中耳积液来提高诊断质量,从而改善治疗效果。这项正在进行的研究旨在分析丹麦在鼓室导抗图检查(2006年11月)纳入医保报销且有临床指征时其使用情况。我们的研究问题是:有多少诊所使用鼓室导抗图检查?其使用频率如何?使用量是否在增加?诊所中全科医生的数量与鼓室导抗图检查的使用有无关联?
我们利用丹麦国家医疗服务体系中三个地区的信息来分析2007年至2009年期间全科医疗中鼓室导抗图检查的使用情况。这些地区全科医生的覆盖比例为100%。
这三个地区的人口约占丹麦总人口的一半。2009年的资料涉及902家不同诊所及1700多名全科医生。2007年,55%的诊所进行鼓室导抗图检查,2009年这一比例为60%。在进行鼓室导抗图检查的诊所中,每位全科医生每年鼓室导抗图检查的中位数为28次(四分位间距为13 - 53次)。鼓室导抗图检查使用情况的差异惊人地大,从每位全科医生每年零次或几次到最多每年超过500次鼓室导抗图检查。这种巨大差异值得探讨。
可以给出很多答案。部分解释是进行正确鼓室导抗图检查存在问题,以及理解曲线和数据的临床意义存在问题。