*Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, †Division of Rhinology, ‡Division of Facial Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, and §Director of Facial Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, Johns Hopkins School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland, U.S.A.
Otol Neurotol. 2014 Jan;35(1):182-7. doi: 10.1097/MAO.0b013e3182a1ea8a.
Assess the ability of facial reanimation surgery to restore affect display in patients with severe facial paralysis.
Survey of healthy observers' perception of change in facial visage from preoperative to postoperative state.
Academic tertiary referral center.
Observer graded affect display.
Ninety naive observers completed a survey with pictures of paralyzed faces, smiling and in repose, before and after surgery, as well as normal comparison faces. Observers characterized affect display of each face coded in primary affects from the Derogatis Affects Balance Scale. Results were analyzed with latent class analysis and regression using a three-class model.
Preoperatively, paralyzed faces in repose were most likely to be considered negative (56.0%), then neutral (41.3%) and positive (2.7%). In this same cohort of patients in repose, reanimation surgery restored affect display to normal levels: decreasing negative classification (18.9%) and increasing neutral (53.4%) and positive (27.7%) classification. Hypothesis testing revealed no statistically significant differences in the mean classification probabilities for postoperative faces in repose versus normal faces in repose. The same analysis was performed for smiling faces, which showed marked improvement with reanimation surgery: decreasing negative (45.6%-11.7%) and increasing positive (26.2%-60.0%) classification. Despite this improvement, there were statistically significant differences in classification of postoperative smiling faces versus normal smiling faces.
Facial reanimation surgery was associated with normalized affect display for faces in repose and improved affect display for smiling faces. These results provide evidence that facial reanimation improves the facial expression of emotion. Further assessment in additional contexts will help better characterize the ability of facial reanimation to mitigate the psychosocial burden associated with facial paralysis.
评估面部再神经支配手术恢复严重面瘫患者表情展示能力。
健康观察者对面部容貌从术前到术后变化感知的调查。
学术三级转诊中心。
观察者评定的表情展示。
90 名无经验观察者完成了一项调查,他们观看了术前和术后瘫痪面部、微笑和静止的照片,以及正常对照面部。观察者根据 Derogatis 情感平衡量表对面部表情进行了编码,并从主要情感上对影响进行分类。结果采用潜在类别分析和回归分析进行分析,使用三分类模型。
术前,静止的瘫痪面部最有可能被认为是负面的(56.0%),其次是中性(41.3%)和正面(2.7%)。在同一队列的静止瘫痪患者中,再神经支配手术使表情恢复到正常水平:减少负面分类(18.9%),增加中性(53.4%)和正面(27.7%)分类。假设检验显示,术后静止面部与正常静止面部的平均分类概率无统计学差异。同样的分析也应用于微笑的面部,再神经支配手术显示出显著改善:减少负面(45.6%-11.7%)和增加正面(26.2%-60.0%)分类。尽管有这种改善,但术后微笑面部的分类与正常微笑面部的分类仍存在统计学差异。
面部再神经支配手术与静止面容的正常表情展示和微笑表情展示的改善相关。这些结果为面部再神经支配术改善情绪表情提供了证据。在其他情况下进一步评估将有助于更好地描述面部再神经支配术减轻面瘫相关心理社会负担的能力。