Al-Shdaifat Emad Adel, Manaf Mohd Rizal Abdul
Department of Community Health, Faculty of Medicine, National University of Malaysia, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.
Indian J Med Sci. 2013 May-Jun;67(5-6):103-16.
Hemodialysis treatment is a costly procedure that requires specific resources. It has a considerable burden on patients, caregivers, and healthcare system. The aim of this study was to estimate the economic burden borne by the Ministry of Health (MOH) in Jordan, with a focus on direct medical, direct non-medical, and indirect cost.
The study was conducted at MOH hospitals in Jordan, from August to November 2010. A total of 138 patients and 49 caregivers were involved in the study. An economic evaluation study was used to analyze the burden of hemodialysis treatment at MOH, Jordan. Direct medical costs were estimated through micro and macro costing from the provider's perspective. Patients' and caregivers' costs were included to calculate direct non-medical costs. Human capital approach was employed to evaluate the productivity loss for indirect cost and premature death and potential year life loss was used to estimate the premature death cost.
The total burden of hemodialysis at MOH, Jordan was USD17.70 million per year. Cost per session was $72 and the annual cost per patient was $9976. Direct medical cost was $7.20 million (41%) and direct non-medical cost was $2.02 million (11%). On the other hand, indirect cost (productivity loss) was $8.48 million (48%). All 722 patients on hemodialysis at MOH hospitals consumed 2.7% of MOH budget.
Costs of treating and managing patients on hemodialysis at MOH hospitals in Jordan are substantial. Therefore, efforts should be taken to slow down the progress of renal failure to save resources and a comparative study with other modalities, such as continuous ambulatory peritoneal dialysis and kidney transplantation, should be considered.
血液透析治疗是一个成本高昂的过程,需要特定资源。它给患者、护理人员和医疗保健系统带来了相当大的负担。本研究的目的是估计约旦卫生部所承担的经济负担,重点是直接医疗成本、直接非医疗成本和间接成本。
该研究于2010年8月至11月在约旦的卫生部医院进行。共有138名患者和49名护理人员参与了研究。采用经济评估研究来分析约旦卫生部血液透析治疗的负担。从提供者的角度通过微观和宏观成本核算来估计直接医疗成本。纳入患者和护理人员的成本以计算直接非医疗成本。采用人力资本法评估间接成本的生产力损失,并使用过早死亡和潜在寿命损失年数来估计过早死亡成本。
约旦卫生部血液透析的总负担为每年1770万美元。每次治疗费用为72美元,每名患者每年的费用为9976美元。直接医疗成本为720万美元(41%),直接非医疗成本为202万美元(11%)。另一方面,间接成本(生产力损失)为848万美元(48%)。卫生部医院所有722名接受血液透析的患者消耗了卫生部预算的2.7%。
约旦卫生部医院治疗和管理血液透析患者的成本很高。因此,应努力减缓肾衰竭的进展以节省资源,并应考虑与其他治疗方式,如持续性非卧床腹膜透析和肾移植进行比较研究。