Mannila Vilma, Sipilä Outi
HUS Helsinki Medical Imaging Center, Helsinki University Central Hospital, Helsinki, Finland ; Department of Physics, University of Helsinki, Helsinki, Finland.
Acta Radiol Short Rep. 2013 Dec 11;2(8):2047981613511967. doi: 10.1177/2047981613511967. eCollection 2013.
Recommended phantom-based quality assurance measurements in B-mode ultrasound (US) may be tedious. For the purpose of cost-effective US quality assurance it is important to evaluate measurements that effectively reflect the quality of US scanner.
To find out which recommended phantom-based quality assurance measurements are effective in detecting dead or weak transducer elements or channels in US scanners when visual image analysis and manual measurements are used.
Altogether 66 transducers from 33 US scanners were measured using a general purpose phantom and a transducer tester. The measurements were divided into two groups. Group I consisted of phantom-based uniformity measurement, imaging the air with a clean transducer (air image) and measuring the transducer with the transducer tester, and group II of phantom-based measurements of depth of penetration, beam profile, near field, axial and lateral resolution, and vertical and horizontal distance accuracy. The group II measurements were compared to group I measurements.
With group I measurements, the results with 20% of the transducers were found defective. With 35% of the transducers the results were considered defective in group II measurements. Concurrent flaws in both groups were found with 11% of the transducers.
Phantom-based measurements of depth of penetration, beam profile, near field, axial and lateral resolution, and vertical and horizontal distance accuracy did not consistently detect dead or weak transducer elements or channels in US scanners.
在B型超声(US)中,推荐的基于体模的质量保证测量可能很繁琐。为了实现具有成本效益的超声质量保证,评估能有效反映超声扫描仪质量的测量方法很重要。
当使用视觉图像分析和手动测量时,找出哪些推荐的基于体模的质量保证测量能有效检测超声扫描仪中损坏或功能较弱的换能器元件或通道。
使用通用体模和换能器测试仪对33台超声扫描仪的66个换能器进行测量。测量分为两组。第一组包括基于体模的均匀性测量、用清洁的换能器对空气成像(空气图像)以及用换能器测试仪测量换能器,第二组包括基于体模的穿透深度、波束轮廓、近场、轴向和横向分辨率以及垂直和水平距离精度的测量。将第二组测量结果与第一组测量结果进行比较。
在第一组测量中,发现20%的换能器结果有缺陷。在第二组测量中,35%的换能器结果被认为有缺陷。两组同时出现缺陷的换能器占11%。
基于体模的穿透深度、波束轮廓、近场、轴向和横向分辨率以及垂直和水平距离精度的测量并不能始终检测出超声扫描仪中损坏或功能较弱的换能器元件或通道。