Center for Health Systems Research, National Institute of Public Health, Cuernavaca, Mexico; Fundación Entornos, A. C., Cuernavaca, Mexico.
Center for Health Systems Research, National Institute of Public Health, Cuernavaca, Mexico.
Injury. 2013 Dec;44 Suppl 4:S4-S10. doi: 10.1016/S0020-1383(13)70206-7.
To assess the reach of three different types of road safety interventions (social marketing, education and law enforcement) implemented as part of the Iniciativa Mexicana de Seguridad Vial y Prevención de Lesiones en el Tránsito (Mexican Initiative for Road Safety and the Prevention of Road Traffic Injuries) among youth in two Mexican cities (Guadalajara-Zapopan, Jalisco and León, Guanajuato), and to examine students' self-reported attitude change after being exposed to these interventions.
A cross-sectional design was utilized to evaluate the reach of the city-wide interventions among a random sample of public and private high school and college students from October to December 2011. A total of 5,114 students completed a self-administered questionnaire.
In both cities, students reported a greater exposure to social marketing (73% in Guadalajara-Zapopan and 64% in León) as compared to educational interventions (29.3% in León and 21.6% in Guadalajara-Zapopan) and law enforcement activities (~12% in both). Among respondents, self-reported attitude change was higher after being exposed to educational interventions than law enforcement. Social marketing yielded the lowest prevalence of self-reported attitude change.
Our results show a potential moderate impact, measured as self-reported attitude change, resulting from the three intervention approaches under study. Future studies should address the intensity of exposure as well as the translation of attitude change into safer behaviors. Information generated by this study could be useful for local authorities in the intervention areas to inform their activities.
评估三种不同类型的道路安全干预措施(社会营销、教育和执法)在墨西哥交通安全和预防道路交通伤害倡议(Iniciativa Mexicana de Seguridad Vial y Prevención de Lesiones en el Tránsito)的两个墨西哥城市(哈利斯科州瓜达拉哈拉-扎波潘和瓜纳华托州莱昂)的实施效果,以及检查学生在接触这些干预措施后的自我报告态度变化。
采用横断面设计,于 2011 年 10 月至 12 月,对来自公立和私立高中及大学的随机样本学生进行了全市范围干预措施的效果评估。共有 5114 名学生完成了自我管理问卷。
在这两个城市,与教育干预(莱昂为 29.3%,瓜达拉哈拉-扎波潘为 21.6%)相比,学生报告了更多的社会营销干预(瓜达拉哈拉-扎波潘为 73%,莱昂为 64%)和执法活动(在两个城市中均约为 12%)。在回答者中,暴露于教育干预后的自我报告态度变化率高于执法干预。社会营销产生的自我报告态度变化率最低。
我们的结果表明,在所研究的三种干预方法中,态度变化的自我报告具有潜在的中度影响。未来的研究应关注暴露的强度以及态度变化转化为更安全行为的程度。这项研究产生的信息可能对干预地区的地方当局有用,为其活动提供信息。