Pluyter Jon R, Rutkowski Anne-F, Jakimowicz Jack J
Department of Information Systems and Management, Tilburg University, Warandelaan 2, 5037 AB, Tilburg, The Netherlands,
Surg Endosc. 2014 May;28(5):1545-54. doi: 10.1007/s00464-013-3350-4. Epub 2014 Jan 8.
Minimal access surgery and, lately, single-incision laparoscopic procedures are challenging and demanding with regard to the skills of the surgeon performing the procedures. This article presents the results of an investigation of the performance and attention focus of 21 medical interns and surgical residents training in an immersive context. That is, training 'in situation', representing more realistically the demands imposed on the surgeons during minimal access surgery.
Twenty-one medical interns and surgical residents participated in simulation trainings in an integrated operating room for laparoscopic surgery. Various physiological measures of body heat expenditure were gathered as indicators of mental strain and attention focus.
The results of the Mann-Whitney test indicated that participants with a poor performance in the two laparoscopic cholecystectomy cases had a significantly (U = 3, p = 0.038) higher heat flux at the start of the procedure (mean 107.08, standard deviation [SD] 24.34) than those who excelled in the two cases (mean 62.64, SD 23.41). Also, the average frontal head temperature of the participants who failed at the task was significantly lower (mean 33.27, SD 0.52) than those who performed well (mean 33.92, SD 0.27).
Surgeons cannot operate in a bubble; thus, they should not be trained in one. Combining heat flux and frontal head temperature could be a good measure of deep involvement and attentional focus during performance of simulated surgical tasks.
微创手术以及近来的单切口腹腔镜手术,对外科医生实施手术的技能而言具有挑战性且要求颇高。本文呈现了一项针对21名医学实习生和外科住院医师在沉浸式环境中培训的表现及注意力焦点的调查结果。也就是说,在“实际情境”中进行培训,更现实地体现了微创手术对外科医生的要求。
21名医学实习生和外科住院医师参与了腹腔镜手术综合手术室中的模拟培训。收集了各种身体热量消耗的生理指标,作为精神紧张和注意力焦点的指标。
曼-惠特尼检验结果表明,在两例腹腔镜胆囊切除术中表现不佳的参与者在手术开始时的热通量显著更高(U = 3,p = 0.038)(均值107.08,标准差[SD] 24.34),高于在这两例手术中表现出色的参与者(均值62.64,SD 23.41)。此外,任务失败的参与者的平均额头温度显著低于表现良好的参与者(均值33.27,SD 0.52)(均值33.92,SD 0.27)。
外科医生不能在孤立的环境中操作;因此,他们也不应在这样的环境中接受培训。在模拟手术任务执行过程中,结合热通量和额头温度可能是衡量深度参与和注意力焦点的良好指标。