Ly Theresa, Korb-Wells Cameron S, Sumpton Daniel, Russo Robert R, Barnsley Les
J Grad Med Educ. 2013 Jun;5(2):232-7. doi: 10.4300/JGME-D-12-00040.1.
Medical officers (trainees) in their first to third postgraduate years (PGY-1-3s) work in complex, busy environments, performing tasks that require concentration and application of learned skills. There are frequently competing demands, and being paged is among the most common.
We quantified and described the effect of interruptions that paging created on the clinical workflow of PGY-1-3s during ward duties.
This prospective study was conducted at 2 teaching hospitals in Sydney, Australia. Medical students were recruited as observers to log interruptions of PGY-1-3s' workflow arising from pages from other members of the hospital team.
Forty-two pairs consisting of a PGY-1-3 trainee and an observer were recruited, with 24 proceeding to data collection. Nursing was the most frequent source of pages (47%); other medical staff accounted for 16% of pages, allied health for 12%, and others for 24% (with pharmacy the most common). Pages commonly involved direct patient care (46%), followed by medication issues (21%). Tasks interrupted by pages encompassed direct patient care (37%), indirect patient care (15%), and documentation (12%). Only 27% of pages were assessed as appropriate and urgent, while 58% were considered appropriate but not urgent, and 16% were not appropriate. Only 38% of pages were judged to be clinically more important than the task they interrupted.
Pages frequently interrupted direct patient care activities for PGY-1-3 trainees, and a significant proportion of pages were identified as either not requiring immediate attention or not appropriate, resulting in potentially avoidable interruptions to clinical workflow. Alternate means of alerting trainees to nonurgent tasks may reduce interruptions and facilitate patient care.
处于医学研究生第一年至第三年(PGY-1-3)的实习医务人员在复杂、繁忙的环境中工作,执行需要集中注意力并运用所学技能的任务。工作中经常存在相互冲突的需求,而被传呼是最常见的情况之一。
我们对传呼造成的干扰对PGY-1-3实习医务人员在病房值班时临床工作流程的影响进行了量化和描述。
这项前瞻性研究在澳大利亚悉尼的两家教学医院进行。招募医学生作为观察员,记录医院团队其他成员传呼导致PGY-1-3实习医务人员工作流程被打断的情况。
招募了42对由一名PGY-1-3实习生和一名观察员组成的人员,其中24对进入数据收集阶段。护理人员是传呼的最常见来源(47%);其他医务人员占传呼的16%,专职医疗人员占12%,其他占24%(其中药房最为常见)。传呼通常涉及直接的患者护理(46%),其次是用药问题(21%)。被传呼打断的任务包括直接患者护理(37%)、间接患者护理(15%)和文件记录(12%)。只有27%的传呼被评估为恰当且紧急,而58%被认为恰当但不紧急,16%不恰当。只有38%的传呼被判定在临床上比它们打断的任务更重要。
传呼频繁打断PGY-1-3实习生的直接患者护理活动,并且很大一部分传呼被确定为要么不需要立即关注,要么不恰当,从而导致临床工作流程出现潜在的可避免干扰。提醒实习生处理非紧急任务的替代方式可能会减少干扰并促进患者护理。