Chatterjee Mitali, Bhattacharya Susmita, Karak Kalpana, Dastidar Sujata G
Department of Microbiology, Herbicure Healthcare Bio-HerbalResearch Foundation, Kolkata, India.
Indian J Med Res. 2013 Oct;138(4):541-8.
BACKGROUND & OBJECTIVES: There has been an extensive invasion of tuberculosis at the global level by multidrug resistant as well as extensively drug resistant organisms. Attempts to recover the pathogen in pure culture have frequently failed since the specimens are often highly contaminated and also due to use of insufficient or over-active decontamination procedures. Hence in the present study different methods of decontamination were tested to evaluate their independent efficacies for culture of Mycobacterium tuberculosis.
A total of 359 samples (241 sputum, 59 urine, 50 endometrium biopsy, 9 pus samples) from clinically suspected cases of tuberculosis were subjected to four different methods of decontamination followed by inoculation in Lowenstein-Jensen medium (LJM), and bilayered medium (BLM) and Kirchner's liquid medium (KLM) to determine the influence of differential decontamination processes. Sputum scanty and positive specimens were graded and each sample was subjected to decontamination by four different techniques.
Treatment of specimens with 4 per cent NaOH yielded minimum recovery of pure cultures, while use of 2 per cent NaOH produced higher number of contaminants compared to other methods of decontamination. Addition of N-acetyl L-cystein (NALC) coupled with 2 per cent NaOH to the samples for decontamination provided fairly reasonable recovery, but the highest number of M. tuberculosis cultures could be obtained when the specimens were treated with tri-sodium phosphate and benzalkonium (TSPB). Among the sputum positive cases recovery of growth of M. tuberculosis was higher with greater number of bacilli present in the specimens. Regarding the influence of culture media, BLM produced not only rapid growth, but reasonably higher rate of isolation of M. tuberculosis.
INTERPRETATION & CONCLUSIONS: Although use of TSPB was found to be an efficient method of decontamination for successful isolation of M. tuberculosis from contaminated samples, both NALC+ 2 per cent NaOH and TSPB also showed significant recovery of M. tuberculosis cultures in BLM that can facilitate early diagnosis and initiation of treatment.
耐多药及广泛耐药结核杆菌在全球范围内广泛传播。由于标本常被高度污染,且净化程序使用不当或过度,试图通过纯培养来分离病原体的尝试常常失败。因此,在本研究中,我们测试了不同的净化方法,以评估它们在结核分枝杆菌培养中的独立效果。
从临床疑似结核病例中收集了359份样本(241份痰液、59份尿液、50份子宫内膜活检样本、9份脓液样本),采用四种不同的净化方法处理,随后接种于罗-琴培养基(LJM)、双层培养基(BLM)和柯氏液体培养基(KLM)中,以确定不同净化过程的影响。对痰液稀少且呈阳性的标本进行分级,并对每个样本采用四种不同技术进行净化处理。
用4%氢氧化钠处理标本后,纯培养物的回收率最低,而与其他净化方法相比,使用2%氢氧化钠产生的污染物数量更多。在样本净化处理中,加入N-乙酰-L-半胱氨酸(NALC)并结合2%氢氧化钠可获得较为合理的回收率,但当标本用磷酸三钠和苯扎氯铵(TSPB)处理时,可获得最多数量的结核分枝杆菌培养物。在痰液阳性病例中,标本中存在的杆菌数量越多,结核分枝杆菌生长的回收率越高。关于培养基的影响,BLM不仅能使结核分枝杆菌快速生长,而且分离率也相对较高。
虽然发现TSPB是从污染样本中成功分离结核分枝杆菌的有效净化方法,但NALC + 2%氢氧化钠和TSPB在BLM中也显示出显著的结核分枝杆菌培养物回收率,这有助于早期诊断和开始治疗。