Department of Nuclear Medicine, First Hospital of Jilin University, 71#, Xinmin Street, Changchun 130021, PR China.
Department of Hematology and Oncology, First Hospital of Jilin University, 71#, Xinmin Street, Changchun 130021, PR China.
Forensic Sci Int. 2014 Mar;236:191.e1-6. doi: 10.1016/j.forsciint.2013.12.015. Epub 2013 Dec 25.
It has been known that mandible ramus flexure is an important morphologic trait for sex determination. However, it will be unavailable when mandible is incomplete or fragmented. Therefore, the anthropometric analysis on incomplete or fragmented mandible becomes more important. The aim of this study is to investigate the sex-discriminant potential of mandible ramus flexure on the Korean three-dimensional (3D) mandible models with anthropometric analysis. The sample consists of 240 three dimensional mandibular models obtained from Korean population (M:F; 120:120, mean age 46.2 y), collected by The Catholic Institute for Applied Anatomy, The Catholic University of Korea. Anthropometric information about 11 metric was taken with Mimics, anthropometry libraries toolkit. These parameters were subjected to different discriminant function analyses using SPSS 17.0. Univariate analyses showed that the resubstitution accuracies for sex determination range from 50.4 to 77.1%. Mandibular flexure upper border (MFUB), maximum ramus vertical height (MRVH), and upper ramus vertical height (URVH) expressed the greatest dimorphism, 72.1 to 77.1%. Bivariate analyses indicated that the combination of MFUB and MRVH hold even higher resubstitution accuracy of 81.7%. Furthermore, the direct and stepwise discriminant analyses with the variables on the upper ramus above flexure could predict sex in 83.3 and 85.0%, respectively. When all variables of mandibular ramus flexure were input in stepwise discriminant analysis, the resubstitution accuracy arrived as high as 88.8%. Therefore, we concluded that the upper ramus above flexure hold the larger potentials than the mandibular ramus flexure itself to predict sexes, and that the equations in bivariate and multivariate analysis from our study will be helpful for sex determination on Korean population in forensic science and law.
众所周知,下颌支弯曲是性别鉴定的一个重要形态特征。然而,当下颌骨不完整或碎裂时,这个特征将不可用。因此,对不完整或碎裂的下颌骨进行人体测量分析变得更为重要。本研究旨在通过对韩国三维(3D)下颌骨模型的人体测量分析,探讨下颌支弯曲在性别鉴定中的潜在作用。该样本由韩国人群的 240 个三维下颌骨模型组成(M:F;120:120,平均年龄 46.2 岁),这些模型是由韩国天主教应用解剖研究所和韩国天主教大学收集的。使用 Mimics 获得了 11 项度量的人体测量信息,使用人类学库工具包。使用 SPSS 17.0 对这些参数进行了不同的判别函数分析。单变量分析显示,性别判定的替换准确率范围为 50.4%至 77.1%。下颌支弯曲上缘(MFUB)、最大下颌支垂直高度(MRVH)和上下颌支垂直高度(URVH)表现出最大的二态性,为 72.1%至 77.1%。双变量分析表明,MFUB 和 MRVH 的组合具有更高的替换准确率,为 81.7%。此外,以上弯曲处上颌支的直接和逐步判别分析可分别预测 83.3%和 85.0%的性别。当逐步判别分析中输入下颌支弯曲的所有变量时,替换准确率高达 88.8%。因此,我们得出结论,在上弯曲处上颌支比下颌支弯曲本身具有更大的性别预测潜力,本研究的双变量和多变量分析中的方程将有助于法医学和法律领域对韩国人群的性别鉴定。