Pittman-Polletta Benjamin, Hsieh Wan-Hsin, Kaur Satvinder, Lo Men-Tzung, Hu Kun
Medical Biodynamics Program, Division of Sleep Medicine, Brigham & Women's Hospital, Boston, MA, USA; Division of Sleep Medicine, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA; Department of Mathematics and Statistics, Boston University, Boston, MA, USA.
Department of Mathematics and Statistics, Boston University, Boston, MA, USA; Research Center for Adaptive Data Analysis, National Central University, Chungli, Taiwan, ROC.
J Neurosci Methods. 2014 Apr 15;226:15-32. doi: 10.1016/j.jneumeth.2014.01.006. Epub 2014 Jan 19.
Phase-amplitude coupling (PAC)--the dependence of the amplitude of one rhythm on the phase of another, lower-frequency rhythm - has recently been used to illuminate cross-frequency coordination in neurophysiological activity. An essential step in measuring PAC is decomposing data to obtain rhythmic components of interest. Current methods of PAC assessment employ narrowband Fourier-based filters, which assume that biological rhythms are stationary, harmonic oscillations. However, biological signals frequently contain irregular and nonstationary features, which may contaminate rhythms of interest and complicate comodulogram interpretation, especially when frequency resolution is limited by short data segments.
To better account for nonstationarities while maintaining sharp frequency resolution in PAC measurement, even for short data segments, we introduce a new method of PAC assessment which utilizes adaptive and more generally broadband decomposition techniques - such as the empirical mode decomposition (EMD). To obtain high frequency resolution PAC measurements, our method distributes the PAC associated with pairs of broadband oscillations over frequency space according to the time-local frequencies of these oscillations.
We compare our novel adaptive approach to a narrowband comodulogram approach on a variety of simulated signals of short duration, studying systematically how different types of nonstationarities affect these methods, as well as on EEG data.
Our results show: (1) narrowband filtering can lead to poor PAC frequency resolution, and inaccuracy and false negatives in PAC assessment; (2) our adaptive approach attains better PAC frequency resolution and is more resistant to nonstationarities and artifacts than traditional comodulograms.
相位-振幅耦合(PAC)——一种节律的振幅对另一种较低频率节律的相位的依赖性——最近已被用于阐明神经生理活动中的跨频率协调。测量PAC的一个关键步骤是分解数据以获得感兴趣的节律成分。当前的PAC评估方法采用基于窄带傅里叶的滤波器,该滤波器假设生物节律是平稳的谐波振荡。然而,生物信号经常包含不规则和非平稳特征,这可能会干扰感兴趣的节律并使共模图解释复杂化,尤其是当频率分辨率受短数据段限制时。
为了在PAC测量中更好地考虑非平稳性,同时保持敏锐的频率分辨率,即使对于短数据段也是如此,我们引入了一种新的PAC评估方法,该方法利用自适应且更普遍的宽带分解技术——如经验模态分解(EMD)。为了获得高频率分辨率的PAC测量结果,我们的方法根据这些振荡的时间局部频率在频率空间上分布与宽带振荡对相关的PAC。
我们将我们新颖的自适应方法与窄带共模图方法在各种短持续时间的模拟信号上进行比较,系统地研究不同类型的非平稳性如何影响这些方法,以及在脑电图数据上的情况。
我们的结果表明:(1)窄带滤波会导致PAC频率分辨率差,以及PAC评估中的不准确和假阴性;(2)我们的自适应方法获得了更好的PAC频率分辨率,并且比传统共模图更能抵抗非平稳性和伪迹。