Laboratory of Psychology and NeuroCognition - CNRS UMR 5105, University of Grenoble Alpes Grenoble, France.
Laboratory of Psychology and NeuroCognition - CNRS UMR 5105, University of Grenoble Alpes Grenoble, France ; Psychology of Sensori-Motor, Affective and Social Development Department, Faculté de Psychologie et des Sciences de l'Education, University of Geneva Geneva, Switzerland.
Front Psychol. 2014 Jan 20;4:1022. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2013.01022. eCollection 2013.
Poor handwriting is a core deficit in Developmental Coordination Disorder (DCD). In a previous study, we compared the evolution of cursive letters handwriting in a girl with DCD throughout her second-grade year with that of typically developing (TD) children. We found that her handwriting evolved much less than that of TD children and remained similar to that of pre-schoolers at all stages, suggesting that her handwriting skills have reached a steady state level. We present here a continuation of this work, in which we focused on the velocity aspects of handwriting in another French child with DCD. Indeed, different velocity patterns have been observed in Chinese and English children with DCD. In the French cursive style of writing, consecutive letters are joined, a major difference with the English script style of writing. We thus analyzed the handwriting of a second-grade French girl with DCD, not only for isolated letters but also for syllables and words, in comparison to that of TD first-graders (6-7 years old; N = 85) and second-graders (7-8 years old; N = 88). Each written track was digitized, and nine kinematic parameters were measured to evaluate writing fluency. Results showed that the productions of the child with DCD were more similar to those of first-graders than to those of second-graders. In line with our previous study, the most discriminative parameters between the child with DCD and TD children were size and mean speed. Moreover, her handwriting was less fluent than that of TD children. In contrast to previous observations, we observed a higher writing velocity of the child with DCD when compared to TD children, whatever the complexity of the item, and no significant difference with TD children in the pausing time during writing. These differences may reflect linguistic specificities. For syllables and words, each letter was treated separately as a single unit, thus reflecting a problem in anticipation and automation.
书写不规范是发育性协调障碍(DCD)的核心缺陷。在之前的研究中,我们比较了一名患有 DCD 的女孩在整个二年级期间草书字母书写的演变过程与典型发育儿童(TD)的演变过程。我们发现,她的书写发展程度远低于 TD 儿童,并且在所有阶段都类似于学龄前儿童,这表明她的书写技能已经达到了稳定水平。我们在这里介绍这项工作的延续部分,其中我们重点研究了另一名患有 DCD 的法国儿童的手写速度方面。事实上,在患有 DCD 的中国和英国儿童中已经观察到不同的速度模式。在法国草书风格的书写中,连续的字母是连接在一起的,这与英语书写风格有很大的不同。因此,我们分析了一名患有 DCD 的二年级法国女孩的书写,不仅针对孤立的字母,还针对音节和单词,与 TD 一年级(6-7 岁;N = 85)和二年级(7-8 岁;N = 88)儿童进行比较。每个书写轨迹都进行了数字化处理,并测量了九个运动学参数以评估书写流畅性。结果表明,患有 DCD 的儿童的书写与一年级儿童的书写更为相似,而与二年级儿童的书写不相似。与我们之前的研究一致,区分患有 DCD 的儿童和 TD 儿童的最具区分性的参数是大小和平均速度。此外,她的书写流畅性不如 TD 儿童。与之前的观察结果相反,我们观察到患有 DCD 的儿童的书写速度高于 TD 儿童,无论项目的复杂性如何,并且在书写过程中的停顿时间与 TD 儿童没有显著差异。这些差异可能反映了语言的特殊性。对于音节和单词,每个字母都作为一个单独的单元进行处理,因此反映了预期和自动化方面的问题。