POPs Research Center, School of Environment, State Key Joint Laboratory of Environment Simulation and Pollution Control, Tsinghua University, Beijing 100084, China.
Toxicological Centre, University of Antwerp, 2610 Wilrijk, Belgium.
Environ Int. 2014 Apr;65:100-6. doi: 10.1016/j.envint.2013.12.011. Epub 2014 Jan 28.
This study documents the temporal variability in concentrations of flame retardants (FRs) in floor dust from three offices in Beijing, China. Dust from Office A (OAD) was collected weekly from March to August, 2012, and sampling of dust from Office B and C (OBD and OCD) was conducted fortnightly (each two weeks) from March to December 2012. With intensive and continuous sampling, we report for the first time on clear and coherent temporal trends of polybrominated diphenyl ethers (PBDEs), novel brominated flame retardants (NBFRs) and phosphorus flame retardants (PFRs) in indoor dust. The observed mean concentrations of ∑9PBDEs, ∑4NBFRs and ∑9PFRs, were 554, 11,100 and 128,000ngg(-1) in OAD; 7560, 5000 and 17,300ngg(-1) in OBD; and 4750, 3550 and 17,200ngg(-1) in OCD, respectively. With exception of PBDEs, concentrations of FRs were elevated in OAD than in OBD and OCD. Two to ten-fold variations were observed between the minimum and maximum concentrations of FRs in the same office, indicating that the sampling moment exerts a substantial influence on the level of FR contamination. Different seasonality was distinctively found between BFRs and PFRs. Except for a few occasional abnormal values, BFR levels in office dust were generally constant among different seasons. The abundance rank order for PFRs was: winter>autumn>summer, with peak values occurring in late winter and early spring. This pattern may be attributable to the fact that PFRs are more sensitive to temperature changes compared to PBDEs and NBFRs owning to their higher volatilities. The absence of significant seasonal variation for BFR concentrations in indoor dust compared to outdoor air and dust concentrations is also discussed.
本研究记录了中国北京三个办公室地板灰尘中阻燃剂 (FRs) 浓度的时间变化。2012 年 3 月至 8 月,每周从办公室 A (OAD) 收集灰尘,2012 年 3 月至 12 月,每两周从办公室 B 和 C (OBD 和 OCD) 采集灰尘。通过密集和连续的采样,我们首次报告了室内灰尘中多溴二苯醚 (PBDEs)、新型溴化阻燃剂 (NBFRs) 和磷阻燃剂 (PFRs) 的清晰连贯的时间趋势。在 OAD 中,∑9PBDEs、∑4NBFRs 和∑9PFRs 的观测平均浓度分别为 554、11100 和 128000ngg(-1);在 OBD 中分别为 7560、5000 和 17300ngg(-1);在 OCD 中分别为 4750、3550 和 17200ngg(-1)。除了 PBDEs 之外,OAD 中 FRs 的浓度高于 OBD 和 OCD。同一办公室中 FRs 的最低和最高浓度之间存在 2 到 10 倍的变化,表明采样时间对 FR 污染水平有很大影响。BFRs 和 PFRs 之间存在明显不同的季节性。除了少数异常值外,不同季节办公室灰尘中的 BFR 水平基本保持不变。PFRs 的丰度等级顺序为:冬季>秋季>夏季,峰值出现在冬末和早春。这种模式可能归因于与 PBDEs 和 NBFRs 相比,PFRs 由于挥发性更高,对温度变化更敏感。与室外空气和灰尘浓度相比,室内灰尘中 BFR 浓度没有明显的季节性变化,也对此进行了讨论。