Mulia Nina, Tam Tammy W, Schmidt Laura A
Psychiatr Serv. 2014 May 1;65(5):626-33. doi: 10.1176/appi.ps.201300188.
This study assessed racial-ethnic disparities in access to high-quality treatment for at-risk drinking and alcohol abuse in the United States and simulated strategies to narrow the gap.
Longitudinal data collected in 2001-2002 and 2004-2005 from the National Epidemiologic Survey on Alcohol and Related Conditions were analyzed to examine racial-ethnic disparities in receipt of alcohol interventions that were provided in primary care and specialty treatment settings and that met published clinical guidelines. The sample consisted of 9,116 respondents who met criteria for at-risk drinking or alcohol abuse in 2001-2002. Simulation analyses projected how disparities in treatment services utilization might change if clinical guidelines promoted access to care in more varied health and human service settings.
Compared with whites, members of racial-ethnic minority groups had less than two-thirds the odds of receiving an alcohol intervention over the roughly four-year study period (odds ratio [OR]=.62, p<.05). This disparity increased after adjustment for socioeconomic confounders and frequency of heavy drinking (adjusted OR=.47, p=.003). The most pronounced disparities were between whites and U.S.-born and foreign-born Hispanics. Simulation analyses suggested that these disparities could be partially mitigated by extending care into nonmedical service venues.
Current efforts to extend evidence-based alcohol interventions into medical settings address an important need but are likely to increase racial-ethnic disparities in access to high-quality treatment. Partial solutions may be found in expanding the range and quality of alcohol-related services provided in alternative delivery sites, including faith-based and social service institutions.
本研究评估了美国在获得针对高危饮酒和酒精滥用的高质量治疗方面的种族和族裔差异,并模拟了缩小差距的策略。
分析了2001 - 2002年和2004 - 2005年从全国酒精及相关疾病流行病学调查中收集的纵向数据,以检查在初级保健和专科治疗环境中提供的、符合已发表临床指南的酒精干预措施接受情况方面的种族和族裔差异。样本包括2001 - 2002年符合高危饮酒或酒精滥用标准的9116名受访者。模拟分析预测了如果临床指南促进在更多样化的健康和人类服务环境中获得护理,治疗服务利用方面的差异可能会如何变化。
与白人相比,在大约四年的研究期间,种族和族裔少数群体接受酒精干预的几率不到三分之二(优势比[OR]=0.62,p<0.05)。在调整社会经济混杂因素和重度饮酒频率后,这种差异有所增加(调整后的OR = 0.47,p = 0.003)。最明显的差异存在于白人与在美国出生和外国出生的西班牙裔之间。模拟分析表明,通过将护理扩展到非医疗服务场所,这些差异可以得到部分缓解。
目前将基于证据的酒精干预措施扩展到医疗环境中的努力满足了一项重要需求,但可能会增加获得高质量治疗方面的种族和族裔差异。部分解决方案可能在于扩大在替代提供场所(包括基于信仰的和社会服务机构)提供的与酒精相关服务的范围和质量。