Collins Karen, McClimens Alex, Mekonnen Stella, Wyld Lynda
Centre for Health and Social Care Research, Faculty of Health and Wellbeing, 32 Collegiate Crescent, Sheffield Hallam University, Sheffield, UK.
Psychooncology. 2014 Aug;23(8):892-7. doi: 10.1002/pon.3500. Epub 2014 Feb 12.
To examine the compass and nature of relevant research and identify gaps in the current evidence in order to determine the priority of future research about breast cancer and intellectual disability (ID).
A scoping study that comprised of a consultation exercise with a wide range of key stakeholders (n = 26) from one northern city (Sheffield) within the UK.
This study identified numerous gaps in the current evidence base. It highlighted a dearth of research that focuses specifically on the information and support needs of women with IDs (and their carers) across the breast cancer patient pathway. Within the interviews, whilst 'reasonable adjustments' were being made and there was evidence of good practice, they were neither strategic nor systematic. Participants suggested that future research should focus on devising protocols to advise on the legal, ethical and clinical imperatives so that clinical governance in this area is assured.
There remains a dearth of research or practice guidelines at every stage of the breast cancer care pathway for women with ID. This may arguably lead to late diagnosis, suboptimal treatment and management and overall survival rates for this group. Further research is needed to understand the specific information and support needs of both women with ID (and their formal and informal carers) through the breast care pathway and to identify appropriate protocols, strategies and interventions in order to address these.
审视相关研究的范围和性质,找出当前证据中的差距,以确定未来关于乳腺癌与智力残疾(ID)研究的优先事项。
开展一项范围界定研究,该研究包括与英国北部一个城市(谢菲尔德)的广泛关键利益相关者(n = 26)进行咨询活动。
本研究发现当前证据基础存在诸多差距。它突出表明,专门针对乳腺癌患者整个病程中患有智力残疾的女性(及其护理人员)的信息和支持需求的研究匮乏。在访谈中,虽然正在进行“合理调整”且有良好实践的证据,但这些调整既缺乏战略性也缺乏系统性。参与者建议,未来的研究应侧重于制定方案,就法律、伦理和临床要务提供建议,以确保该领域的临床治理。
对于患有智力残疾的女性,在乳腺癌护理路径的每个阶段都缺乏研究或实践指南。这可能会导致该群体诊断延迟、治疗和管理欠佳以及总体生存率较低。需要进一步开展研究,以了解患有智力残疾的女性(及其正式和非正式护理人员)在乳腺护理路径中的具体信息和支持需求,并确定适当的方案、策略和干预措施来解决这些问题。