Baldon Rodrigo de Marche, Serrão Fábio Viadanna, Scattone Silva Rodrigo, Piva Sara Regina
Department of Physical Therapy, São Carlos Federal University, São Carlos, Brazil.
J Orthop Sports Phys Ther. 2014 Apr;44(4):240-251, A1-A8. doi: 10.2519/jospt.2014.4940. Epub 2014 Feb 25.
Randomized clinical trial.
To compare the effects of functional stabilization training (FST) versus standard training on knee pain and function, lower-limb and trunk kinematics, trunk muscle endurance, and eccentric hip and knee muscle strength in women with patellofemoral pain.
A combination of hip- and knee-strengthening exercise may be more beneficial than quadriceps strengthening alone to improve pain and function in individuals with patellofemoral pain. However, there is limited evidence of the effectiveness of these exercise programs on the biomechanics of the lower extremity.
Thirty-one women were randomized to either the FST group or standard-training group. Patients attended a baseline assessment session, followed by an 8-week intervention, and were reassessed at the end of the intervention and at 3 months after the intervention. Assessment measures were a 10-cm visual analog scale for pain, the Lower Extremity Functional Scale, and the single-leg triple-hop test. A global rating of change scale was used to measure perceived improvement. Kinematics were assessed during the single-leg squat. Outcome measures also included trunk endurance and eccentric hip and knee muscle strength assessment.
The patients in the FST group had less pain at the 3-month follow-up and greater global improvement and physical function at the end of the intervention compared to those in the standard-training group. Lesser ipsilateral trunk inclination, pelvis contralateral depression, hip adduction, and knee abduction, along with greater pelvis anteversion and hip flexion movement excursions during the single-leg squat, were only observed in the FST group after the intervention. Only those in the FST group had greater eccentric hip abductor and knee flexor strength, as well as greater endurance of the anterior, posterior, and lateral trunk muscles, after training.
An intervention program consisting of hip muscle strengthening and lower-limb and trunk movement control exercises was more beneficial in improving pain, physical function, kinematics, and muscle strength compared to a program of quadriceps-strengthening exercises alone.
随机临床试验。
比较功能稳定训练(FST)与标准训练对髌股疼痛女性患者膝关节疼痛与功能、下肢及躯干运动学、躯干肌肉耐力以及髋部和膝部离心肌肉力量的影响。
对于改善髌股疼痛个体的疼痛和功能,髋部和膝部强化运动相结合可能比单纯股四头肌强化运动更有益。然而,这些运动方案对下肢生物力学有效性的证据有限。
31名女性被随机分为FST组或标准训练组。患者参加基线评估,随后进行为期8周的干预,并在干预结束时和干预后3个月进行重新评估。评估指标包括10厘米视觉模拟疼痛量表、下肢功能量表和单腿三级跳测试。采用整体变化评分量表来衡量感知到的改善情况。在单腿深蹲过程中评估运动学。结果指标还包括躯干耐力以及髋部和膝部离心肌肉力量评估。
与标准训练组相比,FST组患者在3个月随访时疼痛减轻,在干预结束时整体改善和身体功能更好。干预后仅在FST组观察到单腿深蹲时同侧躯干倾斜度较小、对侧骨盆下沉、髋内收和膝外展减少,以及骨盆前倾和髋部屈曲运动幅度增大。训练后,只有FST组患者的髋外展肌和膝屈肌离心力量更大,以及前、后和外侧躯干肌肉耐力更强。
与单纯股四头肌强化训练方案相比,由髋部肌肉强化以及下肢和躯干运动控制练习组成的干预方案在改善疼痛、身体功能、运动学和肌肉力量方面更有益。