Singh Prashant, Kurray Lalit, Agnihotri Abhishek, Das Prasenjit, Verma Anil Kumar, Sreenivas Vishnubhatla, Dattagupta Siddharth, Makharia Govind K
Departments of *Gastroenterology and Human Nutrition †Pathology ‡Biostatistics, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi, India.
J Clin Gastroenterol. 2015 Mar;49(3):212-7. doi: 10.1097/MCG.0000000000000105.
We reviewed our celiac disease (CeD) database to study if anti-tissue transglutaminase (tTG) antibody (ab) titers correlate with severity of villous abnormalities in Indian patients and to find out a cutoff value of anti-tTG ab fold-rise, which could best predict CeD.
Guidelines for diagnosing CeD suggest that biopsy could be avoided in some patients with high anti-tTG ab titer.
We reviewed a cohort of 366 anti-tTG ab-positive individuals in whom duodenal biopsies were performed. Anti-tTG ab was obtained before initiation of gluten-free diet. Anti-tTG ab results were expressed in terms of fold-rise by calculating ratio of observed values with cutoff value. CeD was diagnosed if in addition to positive serology, patients had villous atrophy (>Marsh grade 2) and unequivocal response to gluten-free diet.
The mean anti-tTG fold-rise in groups with Marsh grade ≤2 was 2.6 (±2.5), grade 3a was 4.0 (±3.9), 3b was 5.7 (±5.1), and 3c was 11.8 (±8.0). The positive likelihood ratio for diagnosing CeD was 15.4 and 27.4 at 12- and 14-fold-rise of anti-tTG ab titer, respectively. The positive predictive value of diagnosis of CeD was 100% when anti-tTG ab titer was 14-fold higher over the cutoff value. Fifty-seven (43.9%) individuals with anti-tTG titer rise <2-fold high also had CeD.
As severity of villous abnormality increases, titer of anti-tTG also rises. Presence of villous atrophy can be predicted at very high anti-tTG ab titer. In contrast to emerging belief, mucosal biopsies should be performed even if anti-tTG ab titer is <2 times, because many patients with CeD have low titers.
我们回顾了我们的乳糜泻(CeD)数据库,以研究抗组织转谷氨酰胺酶(tTG)抗体(ab)滴度是否与印度患者绒毛异常的严重程度相关,并找出抗tTG ab升高倍数的临界值,该临界值能够最好地预测CeD。
CeD的诊断指南表明,对于一些抗tTG ab滴度高的患者,可以避免进行活检。
我们回顾了一组366名抗tTG ab阳性且进行了十二指肠活检的个体。在开始无麸质饮食之前检测抗tTG ab。抗tTG ab结果通过计算观察值与临界值的比值以升高倍数表示。如果除了血清学阳性外,患者还存在绒毛萎缩(>马什分级2级)且对无麸质饮食有明确反应,则诊断为CeD。
马什分级≤2级的组中抗tTG升高倍数的平均值为2.6(±2.5),3a级为4.0(±3.9),3b级为5.7(±5.1),3c级为11.8(±8.0)。抗tTG ab滴度升高12倍和14倍时,诊断CeD的阳性似然比分别为15.4和27.4。当抗tTG ab滴度比临界值高14倍时,CeD诊断的阳性预测值为100%。抗tTG滴度升高<2倍的57名(43.9%)个体也患有CeD。
随着绒毛异常严重程度的增加,抗tTG滴度也会升高。在抗tTG ab滴度非常高时可以预测绒毛萎缩的存在。与新出现的观点相反,即使抗tTG ab滴度<2倍,也应进行黏膜活检,因为许多CeD患者滴度较低。