Etmanskie Jill M, Partanen Marita, Siegel Linda S
University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada.
University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada
J Learn Disabil. 2016 Jan-Feb;49(1):21-35. doi: 10.1177/0022219414522706. Epub 2014 Mar 4.
There are some children who encounter unexpected reading difficulties in the fourth grade. This phenomenon has been described as late emerging reading disabilities (LERD). Using Grade 4 as a starting point, this study examined the reading development of 964 children between kindergarten and Grade 7. The results showed that 72.0% of children had typical reading performance in Grade 4, whereas there was 0.7% with poor word reading, 12.6% with poor reading comprehension, 2.5% with poor word reading and comprehension, and 12.2% with borderline performance. We also showed that there were similar proportions of children who had early versus late emerging reading difficulties; however, most of the late emerging poor readers recovered by Grade 7. Furthermore, our study showed that poor comprehenders showed poorer performance than typical readers on word reading, pseudoword decoding, and spelling between Grade 1 and Grade 7 and poorer performance on a working memory task in kindergarten. Overall, this study showed that most children recover from late emerging reading problems and that working memory may be an early indicator for reading comprehension difficulties.
有些孩子在四年级时会遇到意想不到的阅读困难。这种现象被描述为迟发性阅读障碍(LERD)。本研究以四年级为起点,考察了964名从幼儿园到七年级儿童的阅读发展情况。结果显示,四年级时72.0%的儿童阅读表现正常,而单词阅读能力差的占0.7%,阅读理解能力差的占12.6%,单词阅读和理解能力均差的占2.5%,临界表现的占12.2%。我们还发现,早发性和迟发性阅读困难的儿童比例相似;然而,大多数迟发性阅读能力差的儿童到七年级时恢复了。此外,我们的研究表明,在一年级到七年级期间,阅读理解能力差的儿童在单词阅读、假词解码和拼写方面的表现比正常读者差,在幼儿园时执行工作记忆任务的表现也较差。总体而言,本研究表明,大多数儿童能从迟发性阅读问题中恢复,工作记忆可能是阅读理解困难的早期指标。