Tafuri Silvio, Gallone Maria S, Gallone Maria F, Zorico Ivan, Aiello Valeria, Germinario Cinzia
Department of Biomedical Science and Human Oncology; Aldo Moro University of Bari; Bari, Italy.
Education and Medical Science; Aldo Moro University of Bari; Bari, Italy.
Hum Vaccin Immunother. 2014;10(5):1416-20. doi: 10.4161/hv.28268. Epub 2014 Mar 7.
Babies' parents and people who look for information about vaccination often visit anti-vaccine movement's websites, blogs by naturopathic physicians or natural and alternative medicine practitioners. The aim of this work is to provide a quantitative analysis on the type of information available to Italian people regarding vaccination and a quality analysis of websites retrieved through our searches. A quality score was created to evaluate the technical level of websites. A research was performed through Yahoo, Google, and MSN using the keywords "vaccine" and "vaccination," with the function "OR" in order to identify the most frequently used websites. The 2 keywords were input in Italian, and the first 15 pages retrieved by each search engine were analyzed. 149 websites were selected through this methodology. Fifty-three per cent of the websites belonged to associations, groups, or scientific companies, 32.2% (n = 48) consisted of a personal blog and 14.8% (n = 22) belonged to some of the National Health System offices. Among all analyzed websites, 15.4% (n = 23) came from anti-vaccine movement groups. 37.6% reported webmaster name, 67.8% webmaster e-mail, 28.6% indicated the date of the last update and 46.6% the author's name. The quality score for government sites was higher on average than anti-vaccine websites; although, government sites don't use Web 2.0 functions, as the forums.: National Health System institutions who have to promote vaccination cannot avoid investing in web communication because it cannot be managed by private efforts but must be the result of Public Health, private and scientific association, and social movement synergy.
婴儿的父母以及寻求疫苗接种信息的人经常访问反疫苗运动的网站、自然疗法医生或自然与替代医学从业者的博客。这项工作的目的是对意大利民众可获取的疫苗接种信息类型进行定量分析,并对通过我们的搜索检索到的网站进行质量分析。创建了一个质量得分来评估网站的技术水平。通过雅虎、谷歌和MSN进行搜索,使用关键词“疫苗”和“疫苗接种”,并使用“或”功能以识别最常用的网站。这两个关键词用意大利语输入,对每个搜索引擎检索到的前15页进行分析。通过这种方法选择了149个网站。53%的网站属于协会、团体或科学公司,32.2%(n = 48)是个人博客,14.8%(n = 22)属于一些国家卫生系统办公室。在所有分析的网站中,15.4%(n = 23)来自反疫苗运动团体。37.6%的网站报告了网站管理员姓名,67.8%报告了网站管理员电子邮件,28.6%注明了最后更新日期,46.6%注明了作者姓名。政府网站的质量得分平均高于反疫苗网站;尽管政府网站不使用网络2.0功能,如论坛:必须推广疫苗接种的国家卫生系统机构不能避免在网络传播方面进行投资,因为这不能由私人努力来管理,而必须是公共卫生、私人和科学协会以及社会运动协同作用的结果。