McLean Heather R, Bailey Heidi N, Lumley Margaret N
University of Guelph, Canada.
Psychol Psychother. 2014 Dec;87(4):425-46. doi: 10.1111/papt.12025. Epub 2014 Mar 17.
To examine the relations between traditionally assessed early maladaptive schemas and the attachment-specific secure base script (a script-like representation of what individuals expect to happen when they face distress), to inform our understanding of beliefs about the self in relation to others. The present study took an ecologically driven approach, assessing knowledge of the secure base script from descriptions of current relationships.
A cross-sectional design was used.
One hundred forty-six undergraduate students, recruited as part of a larger study on adversity and self-concept, provided narrative descriptions of their current relationships. Narratives were coded for attachment-related 'secure base' content using a secure base script scale for relationship narratives. Early maladaptive schemas were assessed with the Young Schema Questionnaire, and attachment was additionally evaluated using the Experiences in Close Relationships questionnaire.
Self-reported attachment avoidance and anxiety were related to secure base script content in theory-consistent ways. The extent to which participants described secure base script content was inversely associated with four out of five maladaptive schemas characterized most centrally by disconnection from others. Furthermore, these associations remained significant when controlling for self-reported attachment style. Self-reported attachment avoidance and anxiety also were related to maladaptive schemas in a predictable pattern.
Results bridge cognitive and attachment theories, supporting the interrelatedness of secure base script knowledge assessed in current relationships, and schema-related content regarding connectedness with others. Better integration of theories regarding internal representations may serve to enrich psychotherapeutic formulation from a variety of clinical perspectives.
Schema Therapy's (Young, Klosko, & Weishaar, 2003 , Schema therapy: A practitioner's guide. New York: Guilford Press) early maladaptive schemas, with themes of disconnection from others/in relationships, are related to the attachment construct of knowledge of a secure base script. Applying secure base script coding procedure to a relationship speech task provides a potentially valuable performance-based tool for evaluating important attachment related constructs in a brief, non-obtrusive format. Better understanding of how self-schema and attachment constructs are associated may be of benefit to case formulation for psychotherapeutic intervention.
探讨传统评估的早期适应不良图式与依恋特定的安全基地脚本(一种类似脚本的表征,描述个体在面对痛苦时期望发生的事情)之间的关系,以增进我们对自我与他人关系信念的理解。本研究采用生态驱动方法,从当前关系描述中评估安全基地脚本知识。
采用横断面设计。
146名本科生作为一项关于逆境与自我概念的大型研究的一部分被招募,他们提供了对当前关系的叙述性描述。使用关系叙述的安全基地脚本书对叙述进行编码,以获取与依恋相关的“安全基地”内容。使用青年图式问卷评估早期适应不良图式,并使用亲密关系经历问卷对依恋进行额外评估。
自我报告的依恋回避和焦虑与安全基地脚本内容存在理论上一致的关联。参与者描述安全基地脚本内容的程度与以与他人脱节为核心特征的五种适应不良图式中的四种呈负相关。此外,在控制自我报告的依恋风格后,这些关联仍然显著。自我报告的依恋回避和焦虑也以可预测的模式与适应不良图式相关。
研究结果将认知理论和依恋理论联系起来,支持了从当前关系中评估的安全基地脚本知识与关于与他人联系的图式相关内容之间的相互关联性。更好地整合关于内部表征的理论可能有助于从各种临床角度丰富心理治疗的构想。
图式疗法(Young, Klosko, & Weishaar, 2003,《图式疗法:从业者指南》。纽约:吉尔福德出版社)中以与他人/关系脱节为主题的早期适应不良图式与安全基地脚本知识的依恋结构相关。将安全基地脚本书编码程序应用于关系言语任务,为以简短、不唐突的形式评估重要的依恋相关结构提供了一种潜在有价值的基于表现的工具。更好地理解自我图式和依恋结构如何关联可能有助于心理治疗干预的病例构想。