McConeghy Kevin W, Bress Adam, Qato Dima M, Wing Coady, Nutescu Edith A
Department of Pharmacy Practice University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, Illinois.
Pharmacotherapy. 2014 Jun;34(6):561-9. doi: 10.1002/phar.1415. Epub 2014 Mar 19.
Evaluate dabigatran adverse event reports with a reported bleeding event and/or reported fatal outcome compared with warfarin.
Retrospective analysis of the FDA Adverse Event Reporting System (FAERS) database.
We identified reports from October 1, 2010, through December 31, 2011, in the United States listing dabigatran or warfarin as the primary suspected agent. Bleeding events and related outcomes were determined. A bleeding-related mortality rate was calculated based on national dabigatran treatment data.
Dabigatran was the primary suspected agent in 9029 adverse reports. Of these, 2347 (26%) were bleeding events; a fatal outcome was reported in 348 (15%) of the bleeding events. In comparison, warfarin was the suspected agent in 2038 reports, of which 647 (32%) were reported as bleeding events. Among the warfarin bleeding reports, 46 (7.1%) reported a fatal outcome. Based on national dabigatran use and adverse bleed reports with fatal outcomes, we estimate a lower bound of 150 bleeding-related fatalities per 100,000 dabigatran patient-years. Because of underreporting bias, these estimates represent a lower bound on the population bleeding mortality rates.
Reports from FAERS are subject to significant bias but suggest that fatal outcomes among dabigatran reports are higher in clinical practice than they were in controlled clinical trials.
评估达比加群与华法林相比,有出血事件报告和/或致命结局报告的不良事件报告情况。
对美国食品药品监督管理局不良事件报告系统(FAERS)数据库进行回顾性分析。
我们确定了2010年10月1日至2011年12月31日期间美国列出达比加群或华法林为主要可疑药物的报告。确定了出血事件及相关结局。根据全国达比加群治疗数据计算出血相关死亡率。
在9029份不良报告中,达比加群是主要可疑药物。其中,2347份(26%)为出血事件;在这些出血事件中,348份(15%)报告有致命结局。相比之下,在2038份报告中,华法林是可疑药物,其中647份(32%)报告为出血事件。在华法林出血报告中,46份(7.1%)报告有致命结局。根据全国达比加群使用情况及有致命结局的不良出血报告,我们估计每100,000达比加群患者年有150例出血相关死亡的下限。由于报告偏倚,这些估计值代表了总体出血死亡率的下限。
FAERS的报告存在显著偏倚,但表明在临床实践中,达比加群报告中的致命结局高于对照临床试验中的情况。