Cook Joan M, Dinnen Stephanie, Thompson Richard, Simiola Vanessa, Schnurr Paula P
Yale School of Medicine, Department of Psychiatry, New Haven, Connecticut, USA; National Center for PTSD, Evaluation Division, West Haven, Connecticut, USA and Executive Division, White River Junction, Vermont, USA.
J Trauma Stress. 2014 Apr;27(2):137-43. doi: 10.1002/jts.21902. Epub 2014 Mar 25.
There has been little investigation of the natural course of evidence-based treatments (EBTs) over time following the draw-down of initial implementation efforts. Thus, we undertook qualitative interviews with the providers at 38 U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs' residential treatment programs for posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) to understand implementation and adaptation of 2 EBTs, prolonged exposure (PE), and cognitive processing therapy (CPT), at 2 time points over a 4-year period. The number of providers trained in the therapies and level of training improved over time. At baseline, of the 179 providers eligible per VA training requirements, 65 (36.4%) had received VA training in PE and 111 (62.0%) in CPT with 17 (9.5%) completing case consultation or becoming national trainers in both PE and CPT. By follow-up, of the increased number of 190 eligible providers, 87 (45.8%) had received VA training in PE and 135 (71.1%) in CPT, with 69 (36.3%) and 81 (42.6%) achieving certification, respectively. Twenty-two programs (57.9%) reported no change in PE use between baseline and follow-up, whereas 16 (42.1%) reported an increase. Twenty-four (63.2%) programs reported no change in their use of CPT between baseline and follow-up, 12 (31.6%) programs experienced an increase, and 2 (5.2%) programs experienced a decrease in use. A significant number of providers indicated that they made modifications to the manuals (e.g., tailoring, lengthening). Reasons for adaptations are discussed. The need to dedicate time and resources toward the implementation of EBTs is noted.
在最初的实施工作结束后,对于循证治疗(EBTs)随时间推移的自然发展过程,几乎没有进行过研究。因此,我们对美国退伍军人事务部针对创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)的38个住院治疗项目的提供者进行了定性访谈,以了解在4年时间里两个时间点上两种循证治疗方法,即延长暴露疗法(PE)和认知加工疗法(CPT)的实施和调整情况。随着时间的推移,接受这些疗法培训的提供者数量和培训水平都有所提高。在基线时,根据退伍军人事务部的培训要求,符合条件的179名提供者中,有65名(36.4%)接受了退伍军人事务部关于延长暴露疗法的培训,111名(62.0%)接受了认知加工疗法的培训,17名(9.5%)完成了病例咨询或成为延长暴露疗法和认知加工疗法的全国培训师。到随访时,符合条件的提供者增加到190名,其中87名(45.8%)接受了退伍军人事务部关于延长暴露疗法的培训,135名(71.1%)接受了认知加工疗法的培训,分别有69名(36.3%)和81名(42.6%)获得了认证。22个项目(57.9%)报告在基线和随访之间延长暴露疗法的使用没有变化,而16个项目(42.1%)报告有所增加。24个项目(63.2%)报告在基线和随访之间认知加工疗法的使用没有变化,12个项目(31.6%)使用量增加,2个项目(5.2%)使用量减少。大量提供者表示他们对手册进行了修改(例如,调整、加长)。讨论了调整的原因。指出了为循证治疗的实施投入时间和资源的必要性。