Gable Brad D, Gardner Aimee K, Celik Dan H, Bhalla Mary Colleen, Ahmed Rami A
Summa Akron City Hospital, Department of Emergency Medicine, Akron, Ohio ; Ohio University Heritage College of Osteopathic Medicine, Athens, Ohio.
University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center, Dallas, Texas.
West J Emerg Med. 2014 Mar;15(2):199-204. doi: 10.5811/westjem.2013.12.18855.
Obesity is prevalent in the United States. Obese patients have physiologic differences from non-obese individuals. Not only does transport and maintenance of these patients require use of specialized equipment, but it also requires a distinct skill set and knowledge base. To date, there is no literature investigating simulation as a model for educating pre-hospital providers in the care of bariatric patients. The purpose of this study was to determine if a 3-hour educational course with simulation could improve paramedics' knowledge and confidence of bariatric procedures and transport. This study also examined if prior experience with bariatric transport affected training outcomes.
Our study took place in August 2012 during paramedic training sessions. Paramedics completed a pre- and post-test that assessed confidence and knowledge and provided information on previous experience. They had a 30-minute didactic and participated in 2 20-minute hands-on skills portions that reviewed procedural issues in bariatric patients, including airway procedures, peripheral venous and intraosseous access, and cardiopulmonary resuscitation. Study participants took part in one of two simulated patient encounters. Paramedics were challenged with treating emergent traumatic and/or medical conditions, as well as extricating and transporting bariatric patients. Each group underwent a debriefing of the scenario immediately following their case. We measured confidence using a 5-point Likert-type response scale ranging from 1 (strongly disagree) to 5 (strongly agree) on a 7-item questionnaire. We assessed knowledge with 12 multiple choice questions. Paired-sample t-tests were used to compare pre- and post-simulation confidence and knowledge with a significance level of p≤0.05. We used analysis of covariance to examine the effect of previous experiences on pre-and post-educational activity confidence and knowledge with a significance level of p ≤0.05. Proportions and 95% confidence intervals are presented as appropriate. We determined the magnitude of significant pre-post differences with Cohen's d. We assessed scale reliability using Cronbach's alpha and was found to be reliable with scores of 0.83 and 0.88 across pre- and post-test responses, respectively.
Participants exhibited a significant increase in confidence in performing procedures (p<0.01) and knowledge of bariatric patient management (p<0.001) after the simulation. The current study also found an increase in knowledge of transport, vascular access/circulation and airway management (p<0.001). Participant background showed no effects on these changes.
This study suggests that simulation paired with a didactic is an effective method of education for paramedics caring for and transporting bariatric patients. The data show a significant increase in knowledge and confidence with a 3-hour training session, irrespective of previous training or experience with bariatric patients. This is the first study of its kind to apply simulation training for the pre-hospital care of bariatric patients.
肥胖在美国很普遍。肥胖患者与非肥胖个体存在生理差异。运送和护理这些患者不仅需要使用专门设备,还需要一套独特的技能和知识基础。迄今为止,尚无文献研究将模拟作为一种模式来培训院前急救人员护理肥胖症患者。本研究的目的是确定为期3小时的模拟教育课程是否能提高护理人员对肥胖症治疗程序和运送的知识及信心。本研究还考察了既往肥胖症运送经验是否会影响培训效果。
我们的研究于2012年8月在护理人员培训期间进行。护理人员完成了一项评估信心和知识的前后测试,并提供了既往经验的信息。他们参加了30分钟的理论教学,并参与了两个20分钟的实践技能部分,复习了肥胖症患者的治疗程序问题,包括气道处理、外周静脉和骨内通路以及心肺复苏。研究参与者参与了两种模拟患者救治场景中的一种。护理人员面临治疗紧急创伤和/或医疗状况以及解救和运送肥胖症患者的挑战。每组在案例结束后立即对场景进行总结汇报。我们使用一份7项问卷,通过1(强烈不同意)至5(强烈同意)的5级李克特式反应量表来测量信心。我们用12道多项选择题评估知识。采用配对样本t检验比较模拟前后的信心和知识,显著性水平为p≤0.05。我们使用协方差分析来考察既往经验对教育活动前后信心和知识的影响,显著性水平为p≤0.05。适当呈现比例和95%置信区间。我们用科恩d值确定前后显著差异的大小。我们使用克朗巴哈α系数评估量表信度,发现前后测试反应的得分分别为0.83和0.88,量表可靠。
模拟后,参与者在执行程序的信心(p<0.01)和肥胖症患者管理知识(p<0.001)方面有显著提高。本研究还发现,在运送、血管通路/循环和气道管理知识方面有所增加(p<0.001)。参与者背景对这些变化没有影响。
本研究表明,模拟与理论教学相结合是培训护理人员护理和运送肥胖症患者的一种有效教育方法。数据显示,无论之前是否接受过肥胖症患者的培训或有相关经验,经过3小时的培训课程,知识和信心都有显著提高。这是同类研究中首次将模拟培训应用于肥胖症患者的院前护理。