Çelik Güner, Baykan Ömer K, Kara Yakup, Tireli Hülya
Department of Neurology, Faculty of Medicine, Baskent University, Konya, Turkey.
Department of Computer Engineering, Selcuk University, Konya, Turkey.
J Stroke Cerebrovasc Dis. 2014 Jul;23(6):1506-12. doi: 10.1016/j.jstrokecerebrovasdis.2013.12.018. Epub 2014 Mar 25.
The aim of the present study was to evaluate the performance of 2 different multivariate statistical methods and artificial neural networks (ANNs) in predicting the mortality of hemorrhagic and ischemic patients within the first 10 days after stroke.
The multilayer perceptron (MLP) ANN model and multivariate statistical methods (multivariate discriminant analysis [MDA] and logistic regression analysis [LRA]) have been used to predict acute stroke mortality. The data of total 570 patients (230 hemorrhagic and 340 ischemic stroke), who were admitted to the hospital within the first 24 hours after stroke onset, have been used to develop prediction models. The factors affecting the prognosis were used as inputs for prediction models. Survival or death status of the patients was taken as output of the models.
For the MLP method, the accuracies were 99.9% in a training data set and 80.9% in a testing data set for the hemorrhagic group, whereas 97.8% and 75.9% for the ischemic group, respectively. For the MDA method, the training and testing performances were 89.8%, 87.8% and 80.6%, 79.7% for hemorrhagic and ischemic groups, respectively. For the LRA method, the training and testing performances for the hemorrhagic group were 89.7% and 86.1%, and for the ischemic group were 81.7% and 80.9%, respectively.
Training and test performances yielded different results for ischemic and hemorrhagic groups. MLP method was most successful for the training phase, whereas LRA and MDA methods were successful for the test phase. In the hemorrhagic group, higher prediction performances were achieved for both training and testing phases.
本研究旨在评估两种不同的多元统计方法和人工神经网络(ANNs)在预测中风后前10天内出血性和缺血性患者死亡率方面的表现。
多层感知器(MLP)人工神经网络模型和多元统计方法(多元判别分析[MDA]和逻辑回归分析[LRA])已被用于预测急性中风死亡率。共有570例患者(230例出血性中风和340例缺血性中风)的数据,这些患者在中风发作后的前24小时内入院,用于建立预测模型。影响预后的因素被用作预测模型的输入。患者的生存或死亡状态被作为模型的输出。
对于MLP方法,出血性组在训练数据集中的准确率为99.9%,在测试数据集中为80.9%,而缺血性组分别为97.8%和75.9%。对于MDA方法,出血性和缺血性组的训练和测试表现分别为89.8%、87.8%和80.6%、79.7%。对于LRA方法,出血性组的训练和测试表现分别为89.7%和86.1%,缺血性组分别为81.7%和80.9%。
缺血性和出血性组的训练和测试表现产生了不同的结果。MLP方法在训练阶段最成功,而LRA和MDA方法在测试阶段成功。在出血性组中,训练和测试阶段均实现了更高的预测表现。