Macrae Phoebe, Anderson Cheryl, Humbert Ianessa
J Speech Lang Hear Res. 2014 Aug;57(4):1251-8. doi: 10.1044/2014_JSLHR-S-13-0188.
This study examined the effects of chin-down swallowing on laryngeal vestibule closure. It also investigated the technique's rehabilitative impact, by assessing the stability of effects across multiple trials and aftereffects in neutral swallows on cessation of the technique.
Duration of laryngeal vestibule closure (dLVC) was measured with videofluoroscopy in 16 healthy participants (mean = 33.2 years, 9 men). Participants swallowed 40 times: 5 head-neutral swallows (N1), then 30 chin-down swallows, followed by 5 head-neutral swallows (N2). The first 5 chin-down swallows were categorized as early posture swallows (P1) and the last 5 as late posture swallows (P2). Within-participant comparisons determined the effects of the maneuver on dLVC during and after execution.
The study found that dLVC increased during chin-down swallows (N1 to P1, p = .018). This increase remained stable throughout 30 repetitions (P1 to P2, p = .994). On return to neutral, dLVC returned to baseline (N1 to N2, p = .875).
This study demonstrated increased dLVC during chin-down swallowing, offering a possible mechanism responsible for previously reported reduced aspiration during the technique. As aftereffects were not evident after multiple chin-down swallows, the maneuver appears to offer more compensatory benefit than rehabilitative value for patients with dysphagia.
本研究考察了低头吞咽对喉前庭关闭的影响。通过评估该技术在多次试验中的效果稳定性以及在停止该技术后中性吞咽时的后效应,本研究还探究了该技术的康复作用。
对16名健康参与者(平均年龄33.2岁,9名男性)进行视频荧光透视检查,测量喉前庭关闭的持续时间(dLVC)。参与者吞咽40次:先进行5次头部中立位吞咽(N1),然后进行30次低头吞咽,接着再进行5次头部中立位吞咽(N2)。前5次低头吞咽被归类为早期姿势吞咽(P1),后5次为晚期姿势吞咽(P2)。参与者自身比较确定了该动作在执行期间和执行后对dLVC的影响。
研究发现,低头吞咽期间dLVC增加(从N1到P1,p = 0.018)。在30次重复过程中,这种增加保持稳定(从P1到P2,p = 0.994)。恢复到中立位时,dLVC恢复到基线水平(从N1到N2,p = 0.875)。
本研究表明低头吞咽期间dLVC增加,这为该技术先前报道的误吸减少提供了一种可能的机制。由于多次低头吞咽后未出现明显的后效应,该动作对吞咽困难患者似乎提供了更多的代偿益处而非康复价值。