Jenkins Tania M
Brown University, USA
Health (London). 2014 Sep;18(5):526-41. doi: 10.1177/1363459314524800. Epub 2014 Apr 1.
This article uses a Bourdieusian framework to understand the importance of clothing norms for symbolizing and reproducing social, as well as professional, hierarchy in hospitals. Using data from participant observation, it examines how a complex yet informal dress code has emerged at a community hospital in the Northeastern United States, in a setting where very few formal guidelines exist on how to dress. By conceptualizing professionals as holders of various types of capital (economic, cultural, and symbolic), this article expands previous research which considered clothing only as a marker of professional identity. The findings demonstrate (1) how clothing norms are used in subtle, but purposeful, ways to reflect varying degrees of cultural and economic capital and (2) how these complex norms also reflect professional boundaries in medical authority (symbolic capital), which is important during critical moments where clothing can quickly signal who can take control. The discussion borrows Bourdieu's concepts of habitus and field to explain why subordinates subscribe to these clothing norms, in the absence of a formal organizational dress code.
本文运用布迪厄的理论框架来理解着装规范在医院中对社会及职业等级制度进行象征和再生产的重要性。通过参与观察获得的数据,本文考察了在美国东北部一家社区医院中,在几乎没有关于着装的正式指导方针的情况下,一种复杂但非正式的着装规范是如何形成的。通过将专业人员概念化为各种类型资本(经济资本、文化资本和象征资本)的持有者,本文拓展了以往仅将着装视为职业身份标志的研究。研究结果表明:(1)着装规范是以微妙但有目的的方式被用来反映不同程度的文化和经济资本;(2)这些复杂的规范如何也反映了医疗权威中的职业界限(象征资本),这在关键时刻很重要,因为着装能迅速表明谁能掌控局面。讨论借鉴了布迪厄的惯习和场域概念,以解释在没有正式组织着装规范的情况下,下属为何会遵循这些着装规范。