Hartley Tara A, Violanti John M, Mnatsakanova Anna, Andrew Michael E, Burchfiel Cecil M
Int J Emerg Ment Health. 2013;15(4):229-39.
Policing is a stressful occupation and working in this environment may make officers more vulnerable to adverse psychological and physiological outcomes. The impact of prior military experience on work stress and coping strategies has not been well-studied in police. The purpose of this cross-sectional study was to examine differences in levels of police-related stress and coping in officers with and without military experience. Participants were 452 police officers from the Buffalo Cardio-metabolic Occupational Police Stress Study Officers were categorized into three groups: non-military (n = 334), non-combat military (n = 84), and military with combat (n = 34). Age, sex and education adjusted levels of psychological stress and coping measures were compared across the three groups using ANCOVA. P-values were derived from post-hoc comparisons. Non-military police officers had significantly higher stress levels for physically and psychological threatening events compared to non-combat officers (p = 0.019). Non-military officers also reported experiencing significantly more organizational stressors and physically and psychologically threatening events in the past year than combat and non-combat officers (p < 0.05). Combat officers had significantly lower levels of planning and active coping styles compared to non-combat officers (p = 0.026, p = 0.032, respectively) and non-military officers (p = 0.010, p = 0.005, respectively). In summary, police officers without military experience reported experiencing more organizational and life-threatening events than officers who served in the military. Yet combat officers were less likely to utilize positive coping than non-combat and non-military officers. These findings demonstrate the potential positive influence of military experience on police stress. Further research is needed as military veterans return to police work.
警务工作是一项压力巨大的职业,在这种环境下工作可能会使警察更容易出现不良的心理和生理后果。先前的军事经历对警察工作压力和应对策略的影响尚未得到充分研究。这项横断面研究的目的是检验有军事经历和无军事经历的警察在与警务相关的压力水平和应对方式上的差异。参与者是来自布法罗心血管代谢职业警察压力研究的452名警察。警察被分为三组:非军事组(n = 334)、非战斗军事组(n = 84)和有战斗经历的军事组(n = 34)。使用协方差分析比较了三组在年龄、性别和教育程度调整后的心理压力水平和应对措施。P值来自事后比较。与非战斗警察相比,非军事警察在身体和心理威胁事件上的压力水平显著更高(p = 0.019)。非军事警察还报告称,在过去一年中,他们经历的组织压力源以及身体和心理威胁事件比战斗警察和非战斗警察更多(p < 0.05)。与非战斗警察(分别为p = 0.026,p = 0.032)和非军事警察(分别为p = 0.010,p = 0.005)相比,战斗警察的计划和积极应对方式水平显著更低。总之,没有军事经历的警察报告称,他们经历的组织和危及生命的事件比有军事服役经历的警察更多。然而,与非战斗警察和非军事警察相比,战斗警察使用积极应对方式的可能性更小。这些发现证明了军事经历对警察压力的潜在积极影响。随着退伍军人重返警察工作岗位,还需要进一步的研究。