MacKie R M, White S I, Seywright M M, Young H
Department of Dermatology, University of Glasgow, U.K.
Br J Dermatol. 1989 Apr;120(4):511-6. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2133.1989.tb01324.x.
One hundred and six melanocytic lesions were studied to determine the value of the so called Ag NOR technique in differentiating dysplastic naevi, Spitz naevi and spindle cell naevi of Reed from malignant melanoma and from 'banal' compound or intradermal naevi. In 79 cases Ag NOR counts were possible. The banal naevi (36) had a mean count of 1.54, (SD 0.3), and the unequivocally malignant superficial spreading melanomas (13), lentigo maligna melanomas (4) and secondary melanomas (4) had a mean count overall of 3.9 (SD 1.59). For dysplastic naevi (16) the mean Ag NOR count was 1.63 (SD 0.36) and for Spitz and spindle cell naevi (in toto 6) the figure was 1.72 (SD 0.55). The difference in Ag NOR counts between all types of naevi and all types of melanoma was highly statistically significant, but there was no difference between banal naevi and dysplastic, Spitz, and spindle cell naevi. Correlation of Ag NOR counts between three independent observers was good. This technique may, therefore, be a useful adjunct in separating true melanoma from borderline melanocytic naevi.
对106例黑素细胞病变进行了研究,以确定所谓的银染核仁组成区(Ag NOR)技术在鉴别发育异常痣、Spitz痣、Reed梭形细胞痣与恶性黑素瘤以及“普通”复合痣或皮内痣方面的价值。在79例病例中可以进行Ag NOR计数。普通痣(36例)的平均计数为1.54(标准差0.3),明确的恶性浅表扩散性黑素瘤(13例)、恶性雀斑样痣黑素瘤(4例)和继发性黑素瘤(4例)的总体平均计数为3.9(标准差1.59)。发育异常痣(16例)的Ag NOR平均计数为1.63(标准差0.36),Spitz痣和梭形细胞痣(共6例)的数值为1.72(标准差0.55)。所有类型的痣与所有类型的黑素瘤之间的Ag NOR计数差异具有高度统计学意义,但普通痣与发育异常痣、Spitz痣和梭形细胞痣之间没有差异。三位独立观察者之间的Ag NOR计数相关性良好。因此,该技术可能是区分真正的黑素瘤与边缘性黑素细胞痣的有用辅助手段。