Correia-Gomes Carla, Economou Theodoros, Bailey Trevor, Brazdil Pavel, Alban Lis, Niza-Ribeiro João
ICBAS-UP - Department of Population Studies, Instituto de Ciências Biomédicas Abel Salazar - Universidade do Porto, Rua de Jorge Viterbo Ferreira, n°228, 4050-313 Porto, Portugal.
BMC Vet Res. 2014 Apr 28;10:101. doi: 10.1186/1746-6148-10-101.
Transmission models can aid understanding of disease dynamics and are useful in testing the efficiency of control measures. The aim of this study was to formulate an appropriate stochastic Susceptible-Infectious-Resistant/Carrier (SIR) model for Salmonella Typhimurium in pigs and thus estimate the transmission parameters between states.
The transmission parameters were estimated using data from a longitudinal study of three Danish farrow-to-finish pig herds known to be infected. A Bayesian model framework was proposed, which comprised Binomial components for the transition from susceptible to infectious and from infectious to carrier; and a Poisson component for carrier to infectious. Cohort random effects were incorporated into these models to allow for unobserved cohort-specific variables as well as unobserved sources of transmission, thus enabling a more realistic estimation of the transmission parameters. In the case of the transition from susceptible to infectious, the cohort random effects were also time varying. The number of infectious pigs not detected by the parallel testing was treated as unknown, and the probability of non-detection was estimated using information about the sensitivity and specificity of the bacteriological and serological tests. The estimate of the transmission rate from susceptible to infectious was 0.33 [0.06, 1.52], from infectious to carrier was 0.18 [0.14, 0.23] and from carrier to infectious was 0.01 [0.0001, 0.04]. The estimate for the basic reproduction ration (R0) was 1.91 [0.78, 5.24]. The probability of non-detection was estimated to be 0.18 [0.12, 0.25].
The proposed framework for stochastic SIR models was successfully implemented to estimate transmission rate parameters for Salmonella Typhimurium in swine field data. R0 was 1.91, implying that there was dissemination of the infection within pigs of the same cohort. There was significant temporal-cohort variability, especially at the susceptible to infectious stage. The model adequately fitted the data, allowing for both observed and unobserved sources of uncertainty (cohort effects, diagnostic test sensitivity), so leading to more reliable estimates of transmission parameters.
传播模型有助于理解疾病动态,且对测试控制措施的效率很有用。本研究的目的是为猪的鼠伤寒沙门氏菌制定一个合适的随机易感-感染-抗性/携带(SIR)模型,从而估计不同状态之间的传播参数。
利用来自丹麦三个已知感染的从产仔到育肥猪群的纵向研究数据估计传播参数。提出了一个贝叶斯模型框架,该框架包括用于从易感状态转变为感染状态以及从感染状态转变为携带状态的二项式成分;以及用于从携带状态转变为感染状态的泊松成分。将队列随机效应纳入这些模型,以考虑未观察到的队列特异性变量以及未观察到的传播源,从而能够更现实地估计传播参数。在从易感状态转变为感染状态的情况下,队列随机效应也是随时间变化的。平行检测未检测到的感染猪数量被视为未知,并使用有关细菌学和血清学检测的敏感性和特异性信息来估计未检测到的概率。从易感状态到感染状态的传播率估计值为0.33[0.06, 1.52],从感染状态到携带状态为0.18[0.14, 0.23],从携带状态到感染状态为0.01[0.0001, 0.04]。基本繁殖比(R0)的估计值为1.91[0.78, 5.24]。未检测到的概率估计为0.18[0.12, 0.25]。
所提出的随机SIR模型框架成功应用于估计猪场内鼠伤寒沙门氏菌的传播率参数。R0为1.91,这意味着在同一队列的猪中存在感染传播。存在显著的时间-队列变异性,尤其是在从易感状态到感染状态的阶段。该模型充分拟合了数据,考虑了观察到的和未观察到的不确定性来源(队列效应、诊断测试敏感性),从而得出更可靠的传播参数估计值。