Merry Alan F, Weller Jennifer, Mitchell Simon J
J Extra Corpor Technol. 2014 Mar;46(1):7-14.
Most cardiac units achieve excellent results today, but the risk of cardiac surgery is still relatively high, and avoidable harm is common. The story of the Green Lane Cardiothoracic Unit provides an exemplar of excellence, but also illustrates the challenges associated with changes over time and with increases in the size of a unit and the complexity of practice today. The ultimate aim of cardiac surgery should be the best outcomes for (often very sick) patients rather than an undue focus on the prevention of error or adverse events. Measurement is fundamental to improving quality in health care, and the framework of structure, process, and outcome is helpful in considering how best to achieve this. A combination of outcomes (including some indicators of important morbidity) with key measures of process is advocated. There is substantial evidence that failures in teamwork and communication contribute to inefficiency and avoidable harm in cardiac surgery. Minor events are as important as major ones. Six approaches to improving teamwork (and hence outcomes) in cardiac surgery are suggested. These are: 1) subspecialize and replace tribes with teams; 2) sort out the leadership while flattening the gradients of authority; 3) introduce explicit training in effective communication; 4) use checklists, briefings, and debriefings and engage in the process; 5) promote a culture of respect alongside a commitment to excellence and a focus on patients; 6) focus on the performance of the team, not on individuals.
如今,大多数心脏科单位都取得了出色的成果,但心脏手术的风险仍然相对较高,可避免的伤害也很常见。绿色通道心胸外科单位的故事堪称卓越典范,但也说明了随着时间推移、单位规模扩大以及当今医疗实践复杂性增加所带来的挑战。心脏手术的最终目标应该是为(通常病情严重的)患者带来最佳治疗效果,而不是过度关注预防差错或不良事件。衡量是提高医疗质量的基础,结构、过程和结果的框架有助于思考如何最好地实现这一目标。提倡将结果(包括一些重要并发症的指标)与关键过程指标相结合。有大量证据表明,团队协作和沟通方面的失误会导致心脏手术效率低下和可避免的伤害。小事件与大事件同样重要。本文提出了六种改善心脏手术团队协作(从而改善治疗效果)的方法。这些方法是:1)进行亚专业划分,用团队取代群体;2)理清领导关系,同时扁平化权力梯度;3)开展有效的沟通方面的明确培训;4)使用检查表、术前简报和术后总结,并积极参与其中;5)在倡导追求卓越和关注患者的同时,营造尊重的文化氛围;6)关注团队表现,而非个人表现。