Stovold Elizabeth, Beecher Deirdre, Foxlee Ruth, Noel-Storr Anna
Cochrane Airways Group, St George's, University of London, Cranmer Terrace, Tooting, London SW19 2HG, UK.
Syst Rev. 2014 May 29;3:54. doi: 10.1186/2046-4053-3-54.
Cochrane systematic reviews are conducted and reported according to rigorous standards. A study flow diagram must be included in a new review, and there is clear guidance from the PRISMA statement on how to do this. However, for a review update, there is currently no guidance on how study flow diagrams should be presented. To address this, a working group was formed to find a solution and produce guidance on how to use these diagrams in review updates.A number of different options were devised for how these flow diagrams could be used in review updates, and also in cases where multiple searches for a review or review update have been conducted. These options were circulated to the Cochrane information specialist community for consultation and feedback. Following the consultation period, the working group refined the guidance and made the recommendation that for review updates an adapted PRISMA flow diagram should be used, which includes an additional box with the number of previously included studies feeding into the total. Where multiple searches have been conducted, the results should be added together and treated as one set of results.There is no existing guidance for using study flow diagrams in review updates. Our adapted diagram is a simple and pragmatic solution for showing the flow of studies in review updates.
Cochrane系统评价是按照严格的标准进行实施和报告的。新的评价必须包含研究流程图,并且PRISMA声明对如何制作该图有明确的指导。然而,对于评价更新,目前尚无关于应如何呈现研究流程图的指导。为解决这一问题,成立了一个工作组来寻找解决方案,并就如何在评价更新中使用这些图制定指导意见。针对如何在评价更新中使用这些流程图,以及在对一项评价或评价更新进行多次检索的情况下,设计了多种不同的选项。这些选项已分发给Cochrane信息专家群体以征求意见和反馈。在征求意见期之后,工作组完善了指导意见,并建议在评价更新中应使用经过调整的PRISMA流程图,该图应包括一个额外的方框,其中列出纳入总数中的既往纳入研究数量。如果进行了多次检索,应将结果相加并视为一组结果。目前尚无关于在评价更新中使用研究流程图的指导意见。我们调整后的图是展示评价更新中研究流程的一种简单而实用的解决方案。
Children (Basel). 2024-12-20
BMC Health Serv Res. 2025-1-6