Singh Ajai R
Editor, Mens Sana Monographs.
Mens Sana Monogr. 2014 Jan;12(1):35-70. doi: 10.4103/0973-1229.130295.
This paper outlines six important tasks for psychiatry today, which can be put in short as: Spread and scale up services;Talk;Science,Psychotherapy;Integrate; andResearch excellence. As an acronym, STSPIR. Spread and scale up services: Spreading mental health services to uncovered areas, and increasing facilities in covered areas:Mental disorders are leading cause of ill health but bottom of health agenda;Patients face widespread discrimination, human rights violations and lack of facilities;Need to stem the brain drain from developing countries;At any given point, 10% of the adult population report having some mental or behavioural disorder;In India, serious mental disorders affect nearly 80 million people, i.e. combined population of the northern top of India, including Punjab, Haryana, Jammu and Kashmir, Uttarakhand and Himachal Pradesh;Combating imbalance between burden of demand and supply of efficient psychiatric services in all countries, especially in developing ones like India, is the first task before psychiatry today. If ever a greater role for activism were needed, this is the field;The need is to scale up effective and cost-effective treatments and preventive interventions for mental disorders.TALK: Speaking to a wider audience about positive contributions of psychiatry:Being aware of, understanding, and countering, the massive anti-psychiatry propaganda online and elsewhere;Giving a firm answer to anti-psychiatry even while understanding its transformation into mental health consumerism and opposition to reckless medicalisation;Defining normality and abnormality;Bringing about greater precision in diagnosis and care;Motivating those helped by psychiatry to speak up;Setting up informative websites and organising programmes to reduce stigma and spread mental health awareness;Setting up regular columns in psychiatry journals around the globe, called 'Patients Speak', or something similar, wherein those who have been helped get a chance to voice their stories.SCIENCE: Shrugging ambivalence and disagreement and searching for commonalities in psychiatric phenomena;An idiographic orientation which stresses individuality cannot, and should not, preclude the nomothetic or norm laying thrust that is the crux of scientific progress.The major contribution of science has been to recognize such commonalities so they can be researched, categorized and used for human welfare.It is a mistake to stress individuality so much that commonalities are obliterated.While the purpose and approach of psychiatry, as of all medicine, has to be humane and caring, therapeutic advancements and aetiologic understandings are going to result only from a scientific methodology.Just caring is not enough, if you have not mastered the methods of care, which only science can supply.PSYCHOTHERAPY: Psychiatrists continuing to do psychotherapy:Psychotherapy must be clearly defined, its parameters and methods firmly delineated, its proof of effectiveness convincingly demonstrated by evidence based and controlled trials;Psychotherapy research suffers from neglect by the mainstream at present, because of the ascendancy of biological psychiatry;It suffers resource constraints as major sponsors like pharma not interested;Needs funding from some sincere researcher organisations and altruistic sponsors, as also professional societies and governments;Psychotherapy research will have to provide enough irrefutable evidence that it works, with replicable studies that prove it across geographical areas;It will not do for psychiatrists to hand over psychotherapy to clinical psychologists and others.INTEGRATE APPROACHES: Welcoming biological breakthroughs, while supplying psychosocial insights:Experimental breakthroughs, both in aetiology and therapeutics, will come mainly from biology, but the insights and leads can hopefully come from many other fields, especially the psychosocial and philosophical;The biological and the psychological are not exclusive but complementary approaches;Both integration and reductionism are valid. Integration is necessary as an attitude, reductionism is necessary as an approach. Both the biological and the psychosocial must co-exist in the individual psychiatrist, as much as the branch itself.RESEARCH EXCELLENCE: Promoting genuine research alone, and working towards an Indian Nobel Laureate in psychiatry by 2020:To stop promoting poor quality research and researchers, and to stop encouraging sycophants and ladder climbers. To pick up and hone genuine research talent from among faculty and students;Developing consistent quality environs in departments and having Heads of Units who recognize, hone and nurture talent. And who never give in to pessimism and cynicism;Stop being satisfied with the money, power and prestige that comes by wheeling-dealing, groupism and politicking;Infinite vistas of opportunity wait in the wings to unfold and offer opportunities for unravelling the mysteries of the 'mind' to the earnest seeker. Provided he is ready to seek the valuable. Provided he stops holding on to the artificial and the superfluous.
本文概述了当今精神病学的六项重要任务,简而言之可概括为:推广并扩大服务;发声;科学;心理治疗;整合;卓越研究。首字母缩写为STSPIR。
将心理健康服务拓展至未覆盖地区,增加已覆盖地区的设施:精神障碍是健康不佳的主要原因,但在卫生议程中却处于底层;患者面临广泛的歧视、人权侵犯以及设施匮乏的问题;需要阻止发展中国家的人才外流;在任何特定时刻,10%的成年人口报告患有某种精神或行为障碍;在印度,严重精神障碍影响近8000万人,即印度北部包括旁遮普邦、哈里亚纳邦、查谟和克什米尔、北阿坎德邦和喜马偕尔邦在内的人口总和;应对所有国家,尤其是像印度这样的发展中国家,精神科有效服务的需求与供应之间的不平衡,是当今精神病学面临的首要任务。如果说曾经需要更大力度的行动主义,那就是这个领域;需要扩大针对精神障碍的有效且具成本效益的治疗及预防性干预措施。
向更广泛的受众讲述精神病学的积极贡献:意识到、理解并应对网络及其他地方大量的反精神病学宣传;即便理解其转变为心理健康消费主义以及对鲁莽医学化的反对,也要坚定地回应反精神病学;界定正常与异常;提高诊断和护理的精准度;激励那些受益于精神病学的人发声;建立信息丰富的网站并组织项目以减少污名化并传播心理健康意识;在全球各地的精神病学期刊上开设定期专栏,如“患者之声”或类似栏目,让那些得到帮助的人有机会讲述他们的故事。
摒弃矛盾心理和分歧,探寻精神病学现象中的共性;强调个体性的个案研究取向无法也不应排除作为科学进步关键的通则性或规范确立的主旨。科学的主要贡献在于认识到这些共性,以便对其进行研究、分类并用于人类福祉。过分强调个体性以至于共性被忽视是错误的。虽然精神病学以及所有医学的目的和方法都必须是人道且关怀的,但治疗进展和病因理解只能源于科学方法。仅仅关怀是不够的,如果你没有掌握科学所能提供的护理方法。
精神科医生继续开展心理治疗:必须明确界定心理治疗,坚定划定其参数和方法,通过循证和对照试验令人信服地证明其有效性;目前心理治疗研究受到主流的忽视,这是由于生物精神病学占据主导地位;它面临资源限制,因为像制药公司这样的主要赞助商不感兴趣;需要来自一些真诚的研究组织、利他主义赞助商以及专业协会和政府的资金;心理治疗研究必须提供足够无可辩驳的证据证明其有效,要有能在不同地理区域证明其有效性的可重复研究;精神科医生把心理治疗交给临床心理学家及其他人是不行的。
欢迎生物学突破,同时提供社会心理见解:病因学和治疗学方面的实验突破主要将来自生物学,但希望见解和线索能来自许多其他领域,尤其是社会心理和哲学领域;生物学和心理学方法并非相互排斥而是相互补充的;整合和还原论都是有效的。作为一种态度,整合是必要的,作为一种方法,还原论是必要的。生物学和社会心理方法在个体精神科医生身上以及该分支学科本身都必须共存。
仅推动真正的研究,并努力在2020年前让印度有精神病学领域的诺贝尔奖获得者:停止推广质量不佳的研究和研究人员,停止鼓励阿谀奉承者和攀附权贵者。从教师和学生中挑选并培养真正的研究人才;在各部门营造持续的高质量环境,让科室负责人能够识别、培养和培育人才。且永不屈服于悲观主义和犬儒主义;不再满足于通过交易、拉帮结派和政治手段获得的金钱、权力和声望;无数的机会远景在等待展开,为真诚的探索者提供揭开“心灵”奥秘的机会。前提是他准备好去探寻有价值的东西。前提是他不再执着于虚假和多余的东西。