Cho Tack Geun, Kim Young Baeg, Park Seung Won
Department of Neurosurgery, Hallym University Kangnam Sacred Heart Hospital, Hallym University College of Medicine, Seoul, Korea.
Department of Neurosurgery, Spine Center, Chung-Ang University Hospital, Chung-Ang University School of Medicine, Seoul, Korea.
Korean J Spine. 2014 Mar;11(1):1-6. doi: 10.14245/kjs.2014.11.1.1. Epub 2014 Mar 31.
Posterior cervical foraminotomy (PCF) is a motion-preserving surgical technique. The objective was to determine whether PCF alter cervical motion as a long-term influence.
Thirty one patients who followed up more than 36 months after PCF for cervical radiculopathy from January 2004 to September 2008 were enrolled in this study. The range of motion (ROM) of whole cervical spine, the operated segment, the cranial and the caudal adjacent segment were obtained. The clinical result and the change of ROMs were compared with those in the patients performed anterior cervical discectomy and fusion (ACDF) during the same period.
In PCF group, the ROM of whole cervical spine had no significant difference in statistically at preoperative and last follow up. The operated segment ROM was significantly decreased from 11.02±5.72 to 8.82±6.65 (p<0.05). The ROM of cranial adjacent segment was slightly increased from 10.42±5.13 to 11.02±5.41 and the ROM of caudal adjacent segment was decreased from 9.44±6.26 to 8.73±5.92, however these data were not meaningful statistically. In ACDF group, the operated ROM was decreased and unlike in PCF group, especially the ROM of caudal adjacent segment was increased from 9.39±4.21 to 11.33±5.07 (p<0.01).
As part of the long-term effects of PCF on cervical motion, the operated segment motions decreased but were preserved after PCF. However, unlikely after ACDF, the ROMs of the adjacent segment did not increase after PCF. PCF, by maintaining the motion of the operated segment, imposes less stress on the adjacent segments. This may be one of its advantages.
颈椎后路椎间孔切开术(PCF)是一种保留运动功能的手术技术。本研究目的是确定PCF作为一种长期影响因素是否会改变颈椎运动。
纳入2004年1月至2008年9月因神经根型颈椎病接受PCF手术且随访超过36个月的31例患者。测量整个颈椎、手术节段、头侧和尾侧相邻节段的活动度(ROM)。将临床结果和ROM变化与同期接受颈椎前路椎间盘切除融合术(ACDF)的患者进行比较。
PCF组中,整个颈椎的ROM在术前和末次随访时无统计学显著差异。手术节段的ROM从11.02±5.72显著降至8.82±6.65(p<0.05)。头侧相邻节段的ROM从10.42±5.13略有增加至11.02±5.41,尾侧相邻节段的ROM从9.44±6.26降至8.73±5.92,但这些数据无统计学意义。在ACDF组中,手术节段的ROM降低,与PCF组不同,尤其是尾侧相邻节段的ROM从9.39±4.21增加至11.33±5.07(p<0.01)。
作为PCF对颈椎运动的长期影响的一部分,PCF术后手术节段的运动减少但得以保留。然而,与ACDF术后不同,PCF术后相邻节段的ROM并未增加。PCF通过维持手术节段的运动,对相邻节段施加的应力较小。这可能是其优势之一。