绘图对精英运动员3000米跑步成绩的提升:这是一种安慰剂效应吗?
Drafting's improvement of 3000-m running performance in elite athletes: is it a placebo effect?
作者信息
Zouhal Hassane, Ben Abderrahman Abderraouf, Prioux Jacques, Knechtle Beat, Bouguerra Lotfi, Kebsi Wiem, Noakes Timothy D
机构信息
Movement, Sport, and Health Sciences Laboratory, University of Rennes 2, Rennes, France.
出版信息
Int J Sports Physiol Perform. 2015 Mar;10(2):147-52. doi: 10.1123/ijspp.2013-0498. Epub 2014 Jun 6.
PURPOSE
To determine the effect of drafting on running time, physiological response, and rating of perceived exertion (RPE) during 3000-m track running.
METHODS
Ten elite middle- and long-distance runners performed 3 track-running sessions. The 1st session determined maximal oxygen uptake and maximal aerobic speed using a lightweight ambulatory respiratory gas-exchange system (K4B2). The 2nd and the 3rd tests consisted of nondrafting 3000-m running (3000-mND) and 3000-m running with drafting for the 1st 2000 m (3000-mD) performed on the track in a randomized counterbalanced order.
RESULTS
Performance during the 3000-mND (553.59±22.15 s) was significantly slower (P<.05) than during the 3000-mD (544.74±18.72 s). Cardiorespiratory responses were not significantly different between the trials. However, blood lactate concentration was significantly higher (P<.05) after the 3000-mND (16.4±2.3 mmol/L) than after the 3000-mD (13.2±5.6 mmol/L). Athletes perceived the 3000-mND as more strenuous than the 3000-mD (P<.05) (RPE=16.1±0.8 vs 13.1±1.3). Results demonstrate that drafting has a significant effect on performance in highly trained runners.
CONCLUSION
This effect could not be explained by a reduced energy expenditure or cardiorespiratory effort as a result of drafting. This raises the possibility that drafting may aid running performance by both physiological and nonphysiological (ie, psychological) effects.
目的
确定在3000米跑道跑步过程中,尾随气流对跑步时间、生理反应和主观用力程度(RPE)的影响。
方法
10名优秀中长跑运动员进行了3次跑道跑步训练。第一次训练使用轻便的动态呼吸气体交换系统(K4B2)测定最大摄氧量和最大有氧速度。第二次和第三次测试包括在跑道上以随机平衡顺序进行的无尾随气流3000米跑(3000-mND)和前2000米有尾随气流的3000米跑(3000-mD)。
结果
3000-mND的成绩(553.59±22.15秒)明显慢于3000-mD(544.74±18.72秒)(P<0.05)。两次测试的心肺反应无显著差异。然而,3000-mND后的血乳酸浓度(16.4±2.3毫摩尔/升)明显高于3000-mD后(13.2±5.6毫摩尔/升)(P<0.05)。运动员感觉3000-mND比3000-mD更费力(P<0.05)(RPE=16.1±0.8 vs 13.1±1.3)。结果表明,尾随气流对高水平训练运动员的成绩有显著影响。
结论
这种影响不能用尾随气流导致的能量消耗减少或心肺功能努力程度降低来解释。这增加了尾随气流可能通过生理和非生理(即心理)效应来提高跑步成绩的可能性。