At the time of the study, Bart Klijs, Wilma J. Nusselder, Caspar W. Looman, and Johan P. Mackenbach were with the Department of Public Health, Erasmus MC, University Medical Center Rotterdam, The Netherlands. Bart Klijs was also with the Department of Epidemiology, University of Groningen, University Medical Center Groningen, The Netherlands.
Am J Public Health. 2014 Aug;104(8):e141-8. doi: 10.2105/AJPH.2014.301924. Epub 2014 Jun 12.
We assessed the contributions of the prevalence and disabling impact of specific diseases to educational disparities in the prevalence of disability.
We examined a large representative survey of the Dutch population, the Dutch Permanent Survey of Living Conditions (2001-2007; n = 24 883; ages 40-97 years). We attributed the prevalence of disability to chronic diseases by using their empirical associations and assuming independent competing causes of disability. We estimated contributions of prevalence and the disabling impact of diseases to disparities in disability using counterfactuals.
We found that the prevalence of disability in individuals with only an elementary education was 19 to 20 percentage points higher than that in individuals with tertiary education. Sixty-five percent of this difference could be attributed to specific chronic diseases, but more so to their disabling impact (49%-51%) than to their prevalence (20%-29%). Back pain, neck or arm conditions, and peripheral vascular disease contributed most to the disparity in men, and arthritis, back pain, and chronic nonspecific lung disease contributed most to the disparity in women.
Educational disparities in the burden of disability were primarily caused by high disabling impacts of chronic diseases among low educated groups. Tackling disparities might require more effective treatment or rehabilitation of disability in lower socioeconomic groups.
我们评估了特定疾病的患病率和致残影响对残疾患病率教育差异的贡献。
我们研究了一项大型的荷兰代表性人口调查,即荷兰生活条件永久调查(2001-2007 年;n=24883 人;年龄 40-97 岁)。我们通过使用疾病的经验相关性并假设残疾的独立竞争原因,将残疾的患病率归因于慢性疾病。我们使用反事实法来估计疾病的患病率和致残影响对残疾差异的贡献。
我们发现,仅接受过小学教育的个体的残疾患病率比接受过高等教育的个体高 19 到 20 个百分点。这种差异的 65%可以归因于特定的慢性疾病,但更多归因于其致残影响(49%-51%)而不是其患病率(20%-29%)。在男性中,背痛、颈部或手臂疾病以及外周血管疾病对差异的贡献最大,而在女性中,关节炎、背痛和慢性非特异性肺部疾病对差异的贡献最大。
残疾负担的教育差异主要是由于低教育群体中慢性疾病的高致残影响造成的。解决差异可能需要在社会经济地位较低的群体中更有效地治疗或康复残疾。