Fincher Danielle, VanderEnde Kristin, Colbert Kia, Houry Debra, Smith L Shakiyla, Yount Kathryn M
Emory University, Atlanta, GA, USA
Emory University, Atlanta, GA, USA.
J Interpers Violence. 2015 Mar;30(5):818-38. doi: 10.1177/0886260514536280. Epub 2014 Jun 12.
African American women in the United States report intimate partner violence (IPV) more often than the general population of women. Overall, women underreport IPV because of shame, embarrassment, fear of retribution, or low expectation of legal support. African American women may be especially unlikely to report IPV because of poverty, low social support, and past experiences of discrimination. The purpose of this article is to determine the context in which low-income African American women disclose IPV. Consenting African American women receiving Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and Children (WIC) services in WIC clinics were randomized to complete an IPV screening (Revised Conflict Tactics Scales-Short Form) via computer-assisted self-interview (CASI) or face-to-face interview (FTFI). Women (n = 368) reported high rates of lifetime and prior-year verbal (48%, 34%), physical (12%, 7%), sexual (10%, 7%), and any (49%, 36%) IPV, as well as IPV-related injury (13%, 7%). Mode of screening, but not interviewer race, affected disclosure. Women screened via FTFI reported significantly more lifetime and prior-year negotiation (adjusted odds ratio [aOR] = 10.54, 3.97) and more prior-year verbal (aOR = 2.10), sexual (aOR = 4.31), and any (aOR = 2.02) IPV than CASI-screened women. African American women in a WIC setting disclosed IPV more often in face-to-face than computer screening, and race-matching of client and interviewer did not affect disclosure. Findings highlight the potential value of face-to-face screening to identify women at risk of IPV. Programs should weigh the costs and benefits of training staff versus using computer-based technologies to screen for IPV in WIC settings.
美国非裔女性报告亲密伴侣暴力(IPV)的频率高于女性总人口。总体而言,女性因羞耻、尴尬、害怕报复或对法律支持期望低而少报IPV。由于贫困、社会支持少和过去的歧视经历,非裔美国女性可能尤其不太可能报告IPV。本文的目的是确定低收入非裔美国女性披露IPV的背景。在妇女、婴儿和儿童特别补充营养计划(WIC)诊所接受WIC服务的同意参与的非裔美国女性被随机分配通过计算机辅助自我访谈(CASI)或面对面访谈(FTFI)完成IPV筛查(修订冲突策略量表简表)。女性(n = 368)报告了一生中及上一年言语(48%,34%)、身体(12%,7%)、性(10%,7%)和任何形式(49%,36%)IPV的高发生率,以及与IPV相关的伤害(13%,7%)。筛查方式而非访谈者种族影响披露情况。通过FTFI筛查的女性报告的一生中及上一年协商(调整优势比[aOR] = 10.54,3.97)以及上一年言语(aOR = 2.10)、性(aOR = 4.31)和任何形式(aOR = 2.02)IPV显著多于通过CASI筛查的女性。在WIC环境中的非裔美国女性在面对面筛查中比计算机筛查更常披露IPV,并且服务对象与访谈者的种族匹配不影响披露情况。研究结果突出了面对面筛查在识别有IPV风险女性方面的潜在价值。项目应权衡培训工作人员与使用基于计算机的技术在WIC环境中筛查IPV的成本和收益。