McDowell I, Newell C, Rosser W
Department of Epidemiology, University of Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.
J Fam Pract. 1989 Apr;28(4):420-4.
In a randomized trial three ways of increasing rates of cervical screening were compared for women attending a family medicine center. Working from computerized medical records, 1,587 women aged 18 to 35 years who were overdue for a screening test were included in the study. In a control group, no formal method was used to encourage patients to attend for screening, and 13.7 percent obtained a test within the trial year. In one intervention group the physician was issued a message identifying those women visiting the center for a routine appointment who were due for screening; 16.1 percent were screened. Sending a letter to patients in a second group yielded a 25.9 percent compliance rate. In a third group the practice nurse called patients on the telephone to advise them to obtain the test, and 20.0 percent complied. Reminders issued to the physician provide a low-cost, opportunistic approach to reach women who happen to visit the practice, but this approach should be supplemented by telephoning or sending a letter to those women who do not attend regularly.
在一项随机试验中,对一家家庭医疗中心的女性采用三种提高宫颈癌筛查率的方法进行了比较。研究纳入了1587名年龄在18至35岁之间且 overdue for a screening test的女性,数据来自计算机化的医疗记录。在对照组中,未采用任何正式方法鼓励患者进行筛查,在试验年度内有13.7%的人进行了检测。在一个干预组中,医生收到一条信息,识别那些到该中心进行例行预约且 overdue for a screening test的女性,有16.1%的人进行了筛查。在第二组中给患者发送信件,依从率为25.9%。在第三组中,实习护士给患者打电话建议她们进行检测,有20.0%的人照做了。向医生发出提醒是一种低成本的机会性方法,可覆盖到碰巧前来就诊的女性,但对于那些不经常就诊的女性,这种方法应辅以电话联系或发送信件。